![]() |
| Storefront. |
I don't have much to say about the physical business, as I still haven't been there, nor can I tell you much about it, because they don't have a website, and I can't find much about it at all (besides that it opened in 1997). It is a generic NY slice shop. And that is that.
![]() |
| Generic Box. |
I gave up trying to figure it out, until a few months later, when it showed up again ...
"Thick Sliced Pepperoni."
That same night I grabbed a slice of pepperoni. I had no intention of writing a review, nor of even uncovering where the pizza came from, so I took no notes, but I remember thinking it was pretty average pepperoni (where by average I mean NYC average, which is leagues above many other places obviously).
There were really quite a few boxes of pizza, many entirely untouched, like this mushroom one. Growing up, green pepper, onion, and mushroom was my goto pizza, but it had been ages since I had mushroom on pizza. It seems to not really show up much in NY. I snagged a slice of this too.
![]() |
| Margherita. |
"Fresh mozzarella, fresh tomatoes, garlic, pecorino, Stella’s sauce, fresh basil."
This was my first time having Stella's pizza, when an event I attended had it. I grabbed a slice, not knowing where it was from, not expecting anything really.
So, um, I loved this? Not the cooked tomatoes (I just don't care for them), but I loved the tangy sauce and how much there was of it, the cheese was really gooey, and it had TONS of garlic. The fresh basil was good touch. The crust had decent chew.
It is totally generic, no frills pizza but I low key adored it and had more and more and more. 4/5.
14' for $25.41, 18' for $28.89.
![]() |
| Pepperoni (June 2026). |
That same night I grabbed a slice of pepperoni. I had no intention of writing a review, nor of even uncovering where the pizza came from, so I took no notes, but I remember thinking it was pretty average pepperoni (where by average I mean NYC average, which is leagues above many other places obviously).
14" Classic Cheese is $20.06, +$3.25 for the topping, 18" is $22.47 + $4.25 for the topping.
![]() |
| Pepperoni (November 2026). |
A few months passed, and a pile of extra pizzas showed up in the microkitchen at my office. I recognized the generic box instantly, and when I peeked inside the first box, I knew I was in luck: it was the same pizza!
I still had no clue where it was from, but I remembered being charmed by it before, so I quickly grabbed a few slices, starting with the pepperoni (they didn't have the margherita this time).
The slices were large, the crust was crisp and had a great chew (and I really liked the flavor to it, this is the kind of back crust you want to keep, to dunk in something ideally, but even without, not crust you discard). It was well coated in very vibrant tomato sauce. The sauce didn't have much seasoning, but it had a brightness to it. Cheese was also evenly applied, and was nicely melty. The pepperoni were fine, although very greasy, the ones that had cupped literally had pools of oil within.
Again, a very generic slice with nothing special about it, but I wasn't mad at it. High 3/5.
![]() |
| Mushroom. |
For the most part, this was much the same. The crust was a highlight for me due to the flavor and it just kinda hit the spot (in retrospect, I think it really reminded me of the pizza I had in college, when late night slices were ordered, and it was always assumed that you'd want ranch or blue cheese to dip your crusts in). This pie had more sauce than others though, in a way that made it too saucy for me, and it also had more cheese than others, in a way that made it too cheesy. I think the person making it was just heavy handed, but it did detract from my enjoyment of it. The mushrooms were fine, not the slimy canned kind that sometimes is used.
This was my least favorite slice I think because the ratios were more off, but still a high 3/5.






No comments:
Post a Comment