Smash burgers aren't exactly a new thing, but I didn't encounter many prior to this summer when I moved to New York (granted, I hadn't really sought out any kind of burgers in many years, not singling out smash burgers). Somehow though, along with pizza and bagels, I found myself consuming far more burgers since I moved, and smash burgers in particular. I blame 7th Street Burger for giving out so many free burgers during the playoffs, and I got in on that freebie action. After that crazy few weeks, I found myself actually craving burgers for the first time in decades (yes, my blog has a label just for burgers, because many, many years ago, as in, 20 years ago, I regularly lead a group of friends to get burgers every Tuesday night, and when I started blogging I still had some residual burgers adventures).
My burger quest lead me to SMASHED NYC, a small (4 restaurant) chain of fast casual burger restaurants in NY. As you can guess, their main attraction is the smash burgers. It was started during the pandemic, after the chef-owner closed his fine dining bistro.
Sides
SMASHED NYC has a decent number of sides, including of course the mandatory burger place staple of fries (to which you can add several seasonings, or get as chili cheese fries), smashed potatoes (sorta a signature thing, these also can turn into chili cheese smashed potatoes), sweet potato fries, onion rings, and mac and cheese. I tried the smashed potatoes because I wanted to try their unique thing, and onion rings, as I adore those.
![]() |
| Smashed Potatoes. $9. |
That said, they were very well seasoned, herbs and spice too, and they were smashed and had assorted textures and crispy bits. So, fine if you want potatoes ... which I didn't. 2/5 for me but I suspect would be 3 or higher for people who like these sorts of things.
Not pictured is the garlic aioli I had to dunk them in, and that was crazy good. So much garlic. 4.5/5.
The onion rings were very standard, but good. Assorted thick sizes, well battered, the batter didn't fall off too easily. Not particularly interesting batter, but fine. For $5 this felt like a very reasonable portion.
![]() |
| Onion Rings. $5. |
I doubt they make these in-house, likely just a Sysco or whatever product, but they were good. High 3.5/5.
Burgers / Sandwiches
Smashburgers are definitely their main thing, but they do also have a few options for fried chicken sandwiches and hot dogs. Vegans are in luck too, as they have Impossible Burger option. Those who don't want the regular potato bun can opt for a lettuce wrap or gluten-free bun.
For regular burgers, there are 10 different curated burgers to choose from, most of which can be a single, double (+$3), or triple (+$6). These all have different cheeses/aiolis/toppings. Interestingly, none of there are a basic cheeseless burger, the "classic smashed" still has cheese (American, along with both griddled and raw onions, pickles, and their house sauce), but they do allow modifications. The most decadent is the truffle burger, with truffle cheese, truffle butter, onion jam, black truffle sauce, and comes on a brioche bun, for a whopping $28 (which is a normal price for a restaurant burger, but not a fast casual smashburger).
![]() |
| Classic Smashed (Double). $12. |
"Beef Patty, American Cheese, Griddled Onions, Raw Onions, Pickles, SMASHED Sauce on a Martin's Roll."
I went for the classic, to really evaluate the burger in its purest form, not totally loaded down with toppings and fancier sauces. I opted for a double since I knew the patties would be thin.
There were some things I loved about this burger. I loved that they used both onions griddled with the patty and raw onions, and they were generous with it. They were generous with the pickles too. Their SMASHED sauce was good, the cheese was well melted, Martin's roll was as expected, soft, slightly sweet, great match for the burger. The patties themselves were good, nicely griddled and crispy edges, but the beef didn't have that much flavor to it. Overall, I think a low 4/5 maybe 3.5/5 as I really did wish the beef was more flavorful.
I feel I must compare this to 7th Street Burger, the other NYC smashburgers I've had a lot recently. Flavor of the beef-wise, 7th Street definitely wins. They are equals on cheese and bun. Smashed though definitely wins on the other toppings, and they contribute so much flavor to the overall eating experience, I think it gets a slight leg up, although it is also pricier, so that could give another point towards 7th Street, making it a draw.
The $9 price (for a single, this was double, so $12) was reasonable compared to fast food chains, but still a lot more than 7th Street Burger, which I enjoyed even more.
![]() |
| Vegan Classic Smashed (Double). $13. |
"Impossible Patty, Vegan Cheese, Griddled Onions, Raw Onions, Pickles, SMASHED Sauce on an Arnold's Potato Roll."
I also got a vegan burger to take home for later, as I was really strangely craving one, after having a really great vegetarian burger at PLNT a few weeks ago. I've been craving one every since. I again just got the classic, double.
It was basically exactly the same, but with Impossible meat, which clearly doesn't smash in quite the same way. The texture inside was pretty mushy, even though it looked seriously identical on the outside. I grew sick of the taste of the Impossible meat pretty quickly, and the mushy quality was off putting. PLNT wins by a landslide on the vegan burger contest. Oh, this also had vegan cheese, which was fine, it melted nicely and didn't have too much funk to it.
The vegan burgers cost $1 more than their regular counterparts.
The toppings and bun were solid 3.5/5 but the patties ... eh. This falls to a 2.5/5 overall and is definitely not something I'd get again.
























