If you ask New Yorker's the best cheesecake, you'll get a variety of answers. My personal favorite has been Veniero's, the tourists will all flock to Junior's, and there is a loooong tail of other places that people will swear by. New York is known for cheesecake after all. But one place that does come up frequently on best cheesecake lists is Eileen's Special Cheesecake. Food & Wine named it the best cheesecake in America in 2019.
Like many great stories, Eileen's started by a baker, Eileen, who got talked into selling her cheesecake to friend and neighbors, and eventually as a real bakery in 1975. Her daughters now run the business with her, all family run, all women.
They make, well, cheesecake of course, in 6", 10", or individual tart sizes. They offer a few other items like chocolate covered strawberries (random!), cannoli, and chocolate mousse too, but, cheesecake is obviously the focus. Cheesecakes can be topped with different glazed fruits (strawberry, blueberry, cherry, pineapple, raspberry), or come in specialty flavors like salted caramel, chocolate, cookies n' cream, dulce de leche, banana, chocolate raspberry, birthday cake, and more. They also do make a gluten-free version, a low sugar version, and even a tofu based vegan one. Special flavors like lemon, lemon with raspberry swirl, key lime, mango, coconut, Bailey's, marble, pina colada, red velvet, pumpkin spice, or heart shaped varieties are available with advance order too.
Update Review, Summer 2025
I was visiting my NY office and stumbled into the aftermath of a cheesecake party. With goodies from Eileen's! I was overjoyed when I saw all the boxes lined up.
But ... clearly I was late to the party (well, not invited, technically), but I had enjoyed Eileen's cheesecake in the past, and I could see there was clearly plenty left on the trays and knives that was about to get tossed, so I did my part to ensure no cheesecake was left behind! I managed to salvage quite a bit, as I knew how good Eileen's was from past encounters, and was determined to not let it go to waste. Of course this meant I got to enjoy some knife and plate licking, both of which bring me child-like glee
![]() |
Cheesecake Carnage! |
I tried all four of the fruity cheesecakes (cherry, strawberry, raspberry, blueberry) but skipped the lemon with raspberry swirl and the cookies n' cream, as neither are really my preference. All were still beautifully creamy, not too sweet, and had a nice classic cheesecake flavor. Just classic cheesecake, done right. I found it interesting that I didn't mind the crust crumble in this carnage form - I always lament that most cheesecake has graham cracker crust and complain about it, but here, when I was sorta eating cheesecake mousse rather than actual formed slices, the crumbled graham crust throughout just gave some great texture. It worked, really.
The cherry turned out to be my favorite. It had big pieces of juicy cherry on top, in classic cherry pie style goo. I liked the additional juicy burst from the full cherries. ****.
The raspberry was the least memorable, just raspberry preserves on top of cheesecake. The base was still great, but this isn't one I'd necessarily select myself in the future. ***+.
Blueberry was my second favorite, nice to have a berry other than the red berries, as the flavor was a bit more unique. I think I was also going through a blueberry phase. ****.
The strawberry was clearly a crowd favorite, as I didn't get much of the topping besides the goo. I think this normally has big full berries perched on top. Hard for me to evaluate, although the cheesecake and goo were tasty of course.
![]() |
Cherry. 10". $58. |
![]() |
Raspberry. 10". $58. |
![]() |
Blueberry. 10". $58. |
![]() |
Strawberry. 10". $63. |
Interestingly, the strawberry full size cheesecake is $5 more than any of the others, likely due to the more generous amount of real fresh fruit?
![]() |
Grandma Eileen's Chocolate Chip Pound Cake. $24. |
"Chocolate chip pound cake loaf. Serves 8."
I'm not really one for pound cake in general, but given how great Eileen's cheesecakes were when I had them before, and the fact that they make very few items other than cheesecake, I thought this must be decent.
It wasn't. Sorry Grandma Eileen, but I just didn't care for it at all. The exterior tasted slightly burnt. It was flecked with chocolate, but they were flecks, not chips, so no real hits of chocolate. And the base flavor lacked the sugar/butter hit that normally comes with pound cake. It was just ... kinda generic, kinda dry, not very chocolately cake with a slightly burnt finish. Meh. 1/5.
Original Review, Summer 2024
I finally got a chance to try it when we had a party at the office with the individual tarts.
Individual Cheesecake Tarts
The individual tarts do not have tart shells, so not really what I think of as tarts, but rather are cheesecakes in little cupcake style wrappers, individual sized.
![]() |
Strawberry. $6. |
"A creamy cheesecake filling topped with a sweet strawberry glaze and a whole strawberry, nestled in a crisp tart crust."
The first I tried was strawberry, which is the traditional cheesecake with strawberry topping.
This was a very good traditional cheesecake. Dense, NY style, very cream cheese forward, but still fairly fluffy. No hint of lemon, nor touch of vanilla, just, plain, but the sweetness level was good, and it shined in its simplicity. The crust was fairly average compressed crumb crust. The topping was extremely good - it looked like fairly standard strawberry goo from a can, but it was really quite flavorful and the perfect level of sweetness that complimented the plain cheesecake well.
****.
![]() |
Blueberry. $6. |
The blueberry was much the same, same base cheesecake, this time with a thick blueberry compote on top. Again, it looked kinda generic, but I found the sweetness level really ideal, and the thick nature of the compote worked well with the cheesecake. ****.
![]() |
Mango. $6. |
"Creamy cheesecake infused with mango atop a buttery tart crust."
Another dense, NY style cheesecake, but still somewhat fluffy. Strong cream cheese flavor. Mild mango flavor that was light and tropical. Standard crumb crust (I think a missed opportunity to do something like a coconut crust that would go so well with the mango). Quite good, although I do generally go for non-fruity flavors of base cheesecake. ***+.
![]() |
Chocolate Cappuccino. $6. |
"A single-serving cheesecake with a cappuccino-flavored chocolate filling, garnished with a coffee bean."
And finally, a chocolate based one.
This was the most unique of the cheesecakes. The menu description didn't say it, but it had a chocolate crumb crust rather than standard blond graham crust. I greatly preferred this compressed chocolate soil style. The cheesecake itself was much like the others - dense NY style, strong cream cheese flavor, etc, etc. But this one stood out due to how strong the coffee flavor was. Really quite a strong intense coffee flavor, which I really enjoyed, but definitely not one for those who are lukewarm on coffee flavors. ****.