I'm not one for juices or smoothies, so I didn't pay much attention to that extensive part of the menu, besides to note that they really do have far more juices than average. In the morning, I want only one thing: coffee. Regular coffee. Black. And after that first cup, I want more, still black, but, decaf.
Coffee is not the W's strong point. In the lobby, they have complimentary coffee for everyone (regular only, no decaf. Hot only in winter, iced as well in summer), and I just never like it. It always tastes like acid, or is highly bitter, etc. In room, my suite always has a pod based maker, and I never like that either. It makes me sad, because I really, really like my coffee as I roll out of bed.
Since the lobby coffee, and my in-room coffee kept majorly letting me down, I finally decided to splurge and order a french press at breakfast in the restaurant, to see if it was somehow better.
The french press (decaf) was indeed considerably better than the lobby coffee, and the in-room coffee. I wouldn't call it *good* coffee, but, it wasn't horrible. Passable. No real depth nor complexity, but not too much acid or bitterness, and, it was freshly brewed, so that likely helped.
Was this little pot worth $7? Well, no, but, I was a captive audience - it was crazy windy and pouring rain, so even running across the street to Dunkin' seemed out of the question. ***.
The next morning I got it again (for takeout), again a small, which for takeout was a single cup of coffee. It was slightly less good. Higher acid that I recalled from the day before, but still much better than the lobby or in-room coffee.
I was inspired to try the regular coffee too, opting for a large french press the next day. Regular coffee. Black. Large meant two cups as it was takeout.
When I went to pick up my order, the coffee was not included. I went back to ask about it, and had to wait to get the coffee. When I was finally brought the coffee, it had cream and sugar added, which I didn't realize until I got back to my room. Sigh. I contacted them in the app, and they brought me fresh coffee a bit later. It was much, much, much better than the in-room or lobby coffee, clearly fresh, nice and hot, not as much acid or "old" taste to it. Worth $10? Absolutely not. Great coffee? Absolutely not. Better than Dunkin' or Panera literally across the street? Probably not. But, better than the other options on the property, certainly.
***.
Plates & Eggs
The main breakfast lineup is pretty standard: a selection of egg dishes (omelettes, benedicts, platters with eggs your way), a selection of sweet carbs (pancakes, french toast), and then some healthier options like a smoked salmon plate, fruit and yogurt, oatmeal, or granola. Oh, and avocado toast, because that is still a trend in Boston it seems. The only real interesting or creative dishes are those involving waffles - they don't have a regular waffle dish, but rather, use them with fried chicken (chicken and waffles) and as the makings for an egg sandwich.
Over the course of my 5 days, I tried 6 of the main dish options. Nearly all of them I'd get again.
|
Peaches and Cream Pancakes. $18. |
"Buttermilk pancakes, whipped cream."
I'm going to admit something silly. I ordered the pancakes the first morning mostly because I wanted whipped cream to have on hand to use with dessert later in the day. This was the easiest way I could think of to source great whipped cream in my hotel room (there aren't any nearby grocery stores, and I did check the convenience store!). I asked for my toppings on the side, and extra whipped cream, to further my endeavors, and that request was honored (although I'm not sure how much whipped cream they normally give).
The pancakes themselves were pretty average, a stack of three large but thin pancakes. Not really any buttermilk tang. They were well cooked though, not rubbery nor tough, not burnt. But average taste, and not particularly fluffy. **+ pancakes. They came with syrup on the side as well, seemed like pretty standard "breakfast syrup", not real maple syrup, as it was a bit too thick, and a touch cloying.
The other toppings though are where they shined. I wasn't sure what to expect from peaches in December, and to be honest, kinda assumed it was an out of date summer menu and mine would come with something else, but, it did come with a peach topping, albeit not fresh sliced peaches. The peaches were hard to describe, they weren't really like a peach pie filling with lots of goo, but there was some sweet syrup with them. They weren't as cooked down as much as a compote either, still retaining more of a firm texture. Definitely nothing like canned peaches. I guess, stewed or poached sliced peaches? I liked the texture, I liked the sweetness, and I liked the flavor. No real spicing, but just really, well, peachy. I think they would be great on yogurt with a sprinkle of granola for breakfast, or warmed and served with ice cream for dessert. **** peaches.
And finally, the key element: the whipped cream! It was everything I wanted it to be. Lightly sweet, fluffy, and fairly stable, clearly not from a can, so it held up a few days for my assorted uses. A++ would order pancakes again just to get more whipped cream. ****+ whipped cream.
Overall, a fine dish, but I actually think the toppings were best for other uses.
|
Tres Leches French Toast. $20. (Toppings on the side). |
"Brioche, strawberries, bananas, dulce de leche."
I continued to make my way down the menu, moving on to the other sweet warm carb option: french toast. Now, I don't generally care much for french toast, as I find it too eggy, and I'm not really in to soggy bread (which is strange, as I adore bread pudding), but, the previous versions of their french toast were soooo good that I really wanted to try it again. But previously it was literally on the menu as "bread pudding french toast", and was a totally different style, truly, it was bread pudding. Still, I had hope given how great their other french toast variations had been, and the use of brioche and dulce de leche topping of course. I also was just interested in what tres leches would be like in french toast form ...
I asked for my toppings on the side, and when I opened my takeout containers, I'll admit I was let down. It looked like, well, french toast. It didn't look special in any way. Just, french toast. In the other container was fresh sliced banana and strawberries, along with a condiment container of breakfast syrup, one of dulce de leche, and one that I assume was extra tres leches soak.
I half-heartedly picked up a piece of the french toast, and took a bite. And ... wow, what?! It might have looked like any old french toast, but it wasn't. I think it had dulce de leche in the batter, as it was lightly caramelized and had bits of crispy caramel sorta hanging off. You know how french toast often has some eggy legs hanging out the sides? It was like that, but, crispy caramel instead of eggs. OMG. And the thing I don't like about most french toast, the eggy nature, was non-existent. It was also very moist, clearly the tres leches soak helped with that, and the use of brioche meant it soaked up tons of the liquid. So basically, it was super moist, reasonably thick caramelized toast, sorta like bread pudding in slice form. It really didn't remind me of french toast at all, even though it sure looked like fairly regular french toast.
Given how moist and caramelized it was from the batter, I actually didn't really need much of the extra toppings, but the dulce de leche was sweet and delicious, and I was happy to use it for other things (drizzled over roasted plantains and ice cream the next night - yum!). The breakfast syrup was the same as came with the pancakes, not real maple syrup, thick, just sweet, eh. The banana was clearly sliced to order, fresh, not brown, and the berries were not particularly flavorful, and not particularly vibrant, but it was December after all, so I didn't expect otherwise. The extra tres leches soak was essentially I think just sweetened condensed milk, which is never a bad thing, and it helped add moisture and additional sweetness to dish if I wanted it, but again, not really necessary.
Overall, an excellent dish, unlike any other french toast, and really a pleasant surprise. I'd gladly get it again when craving sweet breakfast carbs, or even save it for a dessert later with a scoop of ice cream. ****.
|
Fruit & Berries. $18. |
"Wildflower honey mint yogurt."
Taking a break from just the unhealthy stuff, I opted for fruit & berries (alongside my pile of baked goods of course) one morning. Since I'm allergic to melons, I asked specifically for no melons, assuming they might be included in the fruit mix. I got a fairly substantial serving of rather unripe and uninspired pale yellow pineapple as my "fruit". Previously they gave me banana and apple as well.
For berries, I got a small pile of blueberries, and reasonable piles of blackberries and sliced strawberries. Berries weren't exactly in season (it was December) so their mediocre quality didn't surprise me, and they were fine for the time of year. Generic, grocery store quality berries, but, clearly fresh.
I asked for the yogurt on the side, but I think it is usually just drizzled over as a garnish? Also, note that there are two containers there - only one is yogurt, the other is the milk for my coffee (which confused me, as I had ordered it black).
$18 felt very pricy for essentially a big hunk of pineapple and small berry cup, with a thimble of yogurt. *** quality, but, I kinda want a knock a star for the price.
|
Wildflower Mint Yogurt (with fruit) |
"Wildflower honey mint yogurt."
When I had this dish several years ago, my order was initially missing the yogurt, and when I went back to get it, I seemed to be just plain yogurt. I didn't taste the mint nor honey then. This time, the mint was quite visible, and the yogurt did have a lovely sweetness. It was otherwise fairly average, smooth, lightly runny and not thick like Greek yogurt, yogurt. And just like before, the serving was just this tiny condiment container of yogurt, a single one. It worked as a drizzle, but, this certainly was not a yogurt dish really (granted, the dish name is "fruit and berries", so, I guess that is ok).
***+ yogurt, and I appreciated the mix-ins, even if I laughed at the portion size.
|
Waffle Sandwich. $23. (Hollandaise on the side, sub spinach for bacon, sub American for muenster). |
"Runny egg, bacon, Muenster cheese, Hollandaise sauce."
The next morning, I got experimental, opting for the waffle sandwich.
Ok, I have such mixed feels on this one. If I had just read the menu, I likely would have easily looked over it, as I don't usually go for breakfast sandwiches, don't care for Muenster, and don't like generic waffles. But I had seen photos of it, and knew it used liege waffles, not just regular American flabby breakfast waffles as the "bread". I do adore liege waffles. I also do love hollandaise, although I was curious about the use of hollandaise *in* the waffle sandwich as described. This basically sounded like a breakfast bodega style sandwich, twisted with eggs benedict, and, um, with not one, but two full size liege waffles along for the ride. Oh, and a pile of breakfast potatoes on the side, because, clearly, two eggs, bacon, cheese, hollandaise, and two full waffles isn't enough?
Still skeptical, I ordered it, with a few modifications, that were no problem, even through the app. I asked for American instead of muenster, spinach instead of bacon (as I didn't care for the bacon the previous day), and hollandaise on the side. I figured even if it didn't work well as a composed breakfast sandwich, I could essentially have eggs florentine smothered in hollandaise as my savory course, and waffles for breakfast-dessert.
The waffles were as I expected, given the photos I had seen - likely frozen and heated up, liege style waffles, that many hotels use, that I actually do quite like.
I had some a few months prior my last two mornings at Irmi at Le Meridien in Munich, and wished I had ordered them sooner, so I pushed my skepticism aside and ordered this my second day at the W, because if I loved the waffles, I knew I'd want more. They weren't as crisp as at Irmi, and likely had gotten a bit soft under the room service dome with steam escaping in it, and due to the use in a sandwich with hot items on top of the bottom one, but otherwise, they were good, generic, liege waffles, lightly sweet. ***+.
The egg component was not what I expected. The menu said "runny egg", which I was looking forward to. My sandwich had not one, but two eggs, and both were fully cooked fried eggs. Not even a drop of runny yolk. So, yay for *eggs*, not *egg*, but, boo for no runny yolk. Otherwise they were pretty standard fried eggs, not too rubbery, but, no yolk porn glory. **+.
Next up, the cheese. I was glad I picked American instead of muenster, and it was perfectly melted inside. American cheese has its place, and on a breakfast egg and cheese is one use I certainly approve of. That said, the melty cheese got all over one of the waffles, and that was just a bit odd. I'm all for sweet and savory, but, cheesy waffle wasn't quite what I was looking for. Still, it did kinda work. The spinach I subbed for bacon was sautéed, and not too greasy, and I was glad I opted for that lighter topping. *** cheese and spinach.
What didn't work was the hollandaise. I'm glad I asked for it on the side. It was fairly thick, slightly broken, and far, far too lemon heavy. I'm one to smother things in hollandaise when given the chance, and was looking forward to pouring it all over my eggs, and dunking the potatoes in it, but, after a few bites with it, I pushed it sadly aside. It just wasn't good hollandaise. It also seemed really confused to have hollandaise and cheese on the eggs. I'm not creamy fats averse, but, cheese and hollandaise, together? They muddled each other. I don't think muenster as per the menu would have helped. * for that hollandaise.
The potatoes were crispy, kind greasy, breakfast potato chunks, a style I never like, so after trying one with hollandaise, I pushed them aside to save for my mom, who does like breakfast potatoes. **.
So overall, this was really just a mixed bag, and a dish that left me confused. I was let down by the lack of runny yolk and sub par hollandaise, and felt the hollandaise and cheese didn't belong together. I didn't actually want it as a breakfast sandwich, and the waffles on their own needed more sweetness, as there was no sweet element here besides a touch of pearl sugar in the waffles themselves. I had syrup on hand leftover from my pancakes the day before, and I used that, and was glad I had kept it. Even just a touch of maple in maple bacon or something would help, but I think they just use normal bacon. Still, I appreciate the creative dish, particularly as hotel breakfast menus often have absolutely no flair. I wished I could order just the waffles though, but alas, the waffles alone are not an item on the menu. *** overall.
At $23, this was a fairly pricey dish, but seems worth it - after all, there were two eggs, bacon/cheese/hollandaise, two full liege waffles, AND crispy potatoes with it.
|
Eggs Benedict (Spinach). $24. (Hollandaise and English Muffin on the side). |
"North Country Ham, Smoked Salmon or Sauteed Baby Spinach, Hollandaise with Crispy Potatoes."
When I travel, eggs benedict is kinda my thing. I don't normally like eggs that much in the US, but for some reason, when I travel internationally, I really, really like the eggs. I think there is something different about the taste due to the way they are handled? Or maybe it is my jetlag and wanting savory breakfast? But eggs for breakfast, usually in poached form slathered in hollandaise, as just become my thing when I travel.
Usually when I try eggs in the US while traveling domestically, I am let down, but I still try from time to time. So, my last morning, it was time to finally try the benedict. I again asked for the hollandaise on the side (and the English muffin on the side).
The potatoes were the same as in my previous egg dish, crispy little breakfast potatoes that are not my style, but my mom enjoyed my leftovers. The spinach was also about the same, nicely sautéed spinach, not oily, and nice to have something a bit healthy and savory. The english muffin was lightly warmed/toasted, seemed fresh enough, and didn't come buttered. All basically average reasonable quality components. ***.
The hollandaise I hoped would redeem itself today, I truly hoped it was just a mediocre batch the previous day, but alas, I still didn't care for it at all. Far too strong in the lemon flavor, too thick. I'm glad I asked for it on the side. *.
And finally, the eggs! They were poached very nicely, the yolks just lightly set, yolk came oozing out everywhere when I cut in, and the whites were not rubbery but well set. Pretty textbook. And honestly, better than most US eggs, but not particularly noteworthy taste wise. ***+.
I enjoyed my eggs and spinach drizzled with a little syrup, hot sauce (it came with a little bottle each of ketchup and hot sauce), and lots of salt and pepper, but alas, the hollandaise was not a winner. I actually would have gotten this again had I tried it sooner during my stay, or if I had stayed longer.
|
Avocado Toast. $14. (No Avocado). |
"Multi-grain bread, pickled red onion, heirloom tomato, sunny side up egg."
I didn't actually order this, and I'm still a bit confused how it wound up in my takeout bag, but I didn't notice until I got back to my room that I had avocado-less avocado toast. They *do* know I'm allergic to avocado, so maybe they thought I wanted it this way? But I also didn't order it at all, so, again, confused.
Anyway, since I had opened it, I was told to keep it if I wanted. The toast was good, a thick slice of hearty multi-grain bread, toasted just right, not burnt. The tomato was pretty "meh", very much out of season, mid-December tomato, and it seems like they really should change up the toppings rather than serve such mediocre tomato. The pickled red onions were too harsh for me, but maybe they'd be ok with the creamy avocado and do a nice job cutting that fat? The egg was a nicely cooked sunny side up egg, lightly crispy around the edge, yolk just barely set.
I suspect that with the avocado, and in-season tomato, this could be quite a nice dish if its your sort of thing. I enjoyed the toast and runny egg though. ***.
Sides
On the side, you can opt for any of the breakfast meats (bacon, ham, pork or chicken sausage), breakfast potatoes, toast, yogurt, or fruit. I tried several of the breakfast meats, as I had enjoyed them previously.
|
Applewood Smoked Bacon. $9. |
One morning I was craving something a bit savory to go with my sweet breakfast, so I opted for a side of bacon. I'm pretty fickle when it comes to bacon - I like bacon, but, I don't like it too flabby nor too crispy, and I don't like it too greasy. I also thought it might be nice to toss into my salad at lunch if I didn't finish it with breakfast.
The bacon was fairly average bacon. Not super crispy, not flabby, but also not that well cooked ... the fat not rendered particularly well. It was very greasy. Not really the kind of bacon I like, but the kind my mom always makes, and my dad enjoys.
**.
|
Chicken Sausage. $8. |
I don't actually like chicken, but sometimes I like chicken sausage, and had read a very recent review of someone raving about the chicken sausage, claiming it was the best they ever had.
The sausage was decent - it was very shriveled up, but in a way that worked. Nice snap to it. It had great seasoning, a touch of some savory herb ... sage perhaps? I liked it dunked in the syrup from my pancakes. The serving of 3 for $8 was fairly reasonable.
I wouldn't get this again, but I enjoyed a sausage. ***.
|
Pork Sausage. $8. |
The next day, I got the pork sausage, the one I thought I'd like even more as I like pork and not chicken. I had nearly liked this on prior visits, but it suffered from being far too greasy then.
These sausages also came as a trio, but were bigger and plumper. They were pretty greasy, but not dripping in grease as they had been before. That was all fine, but ... I really did not like the taste. I'm not sure what it was, it really seemed that the base sausage just tasted off to me. There was some herbs, but they weren't the problem. The texture was also fairly grisly inside. I was really not a fan, and after two bites, moved on to other things.
*.
Pastries
In addition to a lineup of toast, bagels, and english muffins, the Gallery has other
baked goods (muffins, croissants), all baked fresh in house daily. During my previous visits, I had found them to be above average, so I was happy to add one or two on to my order every morning, to enjoy a bit later in the day.
The pastries are all priced at $7 each, which is really quite steep. $7 for a muffin or plain (regular sized) croissant? Ooph.
|
Corn Muffin. $7. |
The first day I went for what is usually my favorite type of muffin, a corn muffin. I planned to try it, but mostly use it alongside my leftover roast pork and brussels sprouts with dinner (in the place of cornbread).
The muffin was ok. It was clearly freshly baked, not stale, didn't taste loaded with preservatives, and I loved the crispy top. Good grit to it. That said, it was a bit over baked, you can see how dark the top is, and that made it a bit dry. I wanted it to have a touch more sweetness or depth of flavor too.
It was served warm which was a nice bonus, and with regular butter on the side (honey butter would be great). If this was baked just a few minutes less, it would be ***+, as it was though, just *** for freshness. My least favorite of the muffins.
|
Lemon Poppyseed Muffin. $7. |
The next morning I woke up craving a lemon poppyseed muffin. I have no idea why, but, I woke up, and it was immediately what I wanted. Luckily for me, they have lemon poppyseed on the lineup.
Much like the corn muffin the previous day, it seemed like it had been in the oven a few minutes too long. It was still clearly very fresh, didn't taste preservative-full, was served warm, and had a great crunch from the poppyseeds and pleasant lemon flavor, but, it was just a bit dry, and borderline burnt on top. I used copious amounts of butter and jam to moisten it up, and it was fine, but another victim of over-baking. ***. My second pick of muffins.
|
Chocolate Chunk GF Muffin. $7. |
The next morning, I wasn't craving a muffin given that I ordered the liege waffle sandwich, but still ordered one to enjoy later. Since I was intending it to be dessert essentially, I went all in on the double chocolate chunk. This one is
gluten-free.
It was the first of the muffins that was not over-baked. Like the others, it seemed quite fresh, was served warm, and had a nice crispy top. It looked homemade, rather irregular, and I found its look charming. It was fairly moist inside, and nicely chocolatey. As for the gluten-free nature, I didn't detect anything odd about the texture, the crumb structure, the taste. It tasted like a regular muffin to me.
I think this would be a nice breakfast treat if I was in the mood for a chocolately breakfast, and it made for a nice dessert too when I warmed it back up later and served with a scoop of ice cream and fresh strawberries. My favorite of the muffins. ***+.
|
Chocolate Chunk GF Muffin #2. $7. |
Later in my stay, since I liked it before, I got another chocolate chunk muffin.
I again liked the crispy jagged top, and again it was properly baked unlike the others. It was reasonably moist, and was pretty much just a decent, chocolatey muffin. I still think best turned into dessert, warmed up with ice cream or whipped cream and fresh strawberries. ***.
|
Blueberry Muffin. $7. |
For completeness, since I had tried all the others, I got a blueberry muffin my last morning, intending to try it, and then surprise my Dad with his favorite muffin (just, uh, likely missing a bite).
Just like every other, besides the gluten-free one, it too was over-baked. The top too dark, the entire thing a bit dry. But it was clearly homemade, had funny pieces sticking out that made it charming, and was served warm. It had a reasonable number of juicy berries, and a decent base taste.
A nice muffin, again, *** for freshness, but would easily be ***+ if baked a few mins less. My second favorite.
This one did not come with any butter nor jam, so I was glad I had kept some from prior days.
|
Lemon Poppyseed & Blueberry Muffins #2. $7 each. |
Later in my stay, I ordered more muffins, repeats of the lemon poppyseed and blueberry. They actually were better baked this time, still dark, but not as dark. I was amused by how much, um, "personality" these each had. The lemon poppyseed in particular had all sorts of edges extending out over the base, and was considerably bigger than its blueberry friend.
Both better today, and I really do find the homemade look charming. ***+.
|
Croissant (Chocolate Hazelnut?). $6. |
During my last stay, I discovered the off-menu chocolate croissant, which I think was actually a chocolate hazelnut cream croissant. As you read about then, I wished I'd discovered it sooner, and also, I find it shocking that even 3 years later, they still haven't corrected the menu to include it? Yet they make them every day, so some people must be ordering them ...
Anyway, the croissant wasn't as glorious as my memory. While it did seem freshly baked, it lacked a strong buttery goodness, and wasn't particularly flaky. It was still above average for a hotel croissant though, as it wasn't strangely spongy or stale.
Inside was tasty, although confusing, much like
the one I had the month before at Zutro in Houston. There was a bit of what seemed like melty chocolate, but then, what seemed more like a pastry cream, and tasted strongly of Nutella. On top was a bit of melty chocolate flakes. I really did enjoy the filling, particularly with strawberries and whipped cream that I had on hand. It was reasonably generously filled, although not evenly distributed.
So, better than average for a hotel, but not as good as my memory. I did not find myself wanting another. ***.