Update Reviews, April 2021
![]() |
| Red Velvet. |
![]() |
| Red Velvet: Inside. |
![]() |
| Vanilla Blue. |
![]() | |
| Chocolate Vanilla. |
And last but not least, the double chocolate: chocolate cake with chocolate frosting.
Update Reviews, 2019-2020
Well, I'm sold on SusieCakes now. Some of the items aren't that great, but, their hits are *serious* hits. This is likely my favorite carrot cake in the bay area, the seasonal pumpkin items (bread pudding, pumpkin cheesecake) were top notch, and I've even found new favorites in the cupcake lineup that I truly enjoy.
I had a previous version of this cake, and didn't care for it much at all. But this? This was delicious.
The cake was super moist, with a slight buttermilk tang, and the pudding component made it all that much more moist. The berries were juicy and sweet. The whipped cream made it almost come together like a strawberry shortcake.
I really enjoyed it, and went back for seconds literally immediately. Would gladly get again.
![]() |
| Seasonal: Strawberry Rosé. (August 2019). |
I was drawn in to this one, which turned out to be a seasonal speciality, mostly because it looked different from all other SusieCakes cupcakes. The frosting was piped differently, there were no contrasting colorful sprinkles.
I tasted the frosting first, thinking it would likely taste like strawberries, as it was pink, but I didn't taste the berry flavor I was expecting. Instead, it was sweet, but had a slightly more subtle flavor that I couldn't pinpoint. It didn't seem like the standard SusieCakes pink vanilla buttercream either.
Of course, once I looked it up, I found that indeed, it wasn't the plain vanilla buttercream, it was pink champagne buttercream. I certainly wouldn't have identified it that way, but, it was still good, although very, very, very sweet. More on that soon.
Although the cake is named "rosé", after the sparkling wine I imagine, I'm fairly certain the distinct piping job was done to look like a rose flower, and it really was pretty. It glistened with white pearl sugars on top.
![]() |
| Seasonal: Strawberry Rosé: Inside. |
![]() |
| Strawberry. August 2019. |
Simple vanilla cake, well baked, consistent texture, good crumb. Sweet, quite strawberry forward frosting. Complimentary colored sprinkles. I was impressed with just how fruity that got the frosting.
Nothing particular novel, nor negative with this cupcake. If you like vanilla cake, and strawberry frosting, go for this, a well made cupcake.
![]() |
| Chocolate Chocolate / Coconut / Mocha. August 2019). |
"Chocolate cupcake with coffee buttercream frosting."
From this box I tried what turned out to be the mocha cupcake. When I grabbed it, I was hoping for salted caramel or something in that vein, so I was fairly surprised when I tasted it to find bitter coffee flavored frosting.
Once I re-set my expectations however, I did enjoy it - mocha is a good flavor, when you are prepared for it. Not a flavor I go for often, but, if you like fairly intense coffee flavor, this delivers.
![]() |
| Chocolate Peanut Butter. (August 2019). |
Yes, someone got to this one before me, cutting it in half, but that didn't stop me from snatching up the other half as soon as I realized it was the peanut butter frosted one. Mmm, peanut butter.
The cake base was good, standard chocolate cake, moist enough. The frosting was certainly on the sweet side, ok, it was very sweet, but I could still taste enough peanut butter to make me happy. The chocolate and peanut butter combo is a classic, and it worked as expected here.
This was probably my favorite of the SusieCakes cupcakes, because I'm such a sucker for peanut butter.
October 2019
![]() |
| Cakes, cookies, bars ... |
Seasonal Fall/Halloween Specials
![]() |
| Halloween Celebration Cake. ($38.00 for 6", $52.00 for 9") |
I've had mixed success with SusieCakes cakes before, but this one was basically in the success category. It was the classic funfetti celebration cake, just, turned into a Halloween theme.
The cake base was moist, sweet, and had good buttermilk tang to it. That tang makes such a difference. It was studded with seasonal sprinkles rather than the standard funfetti ones, but they didn't really change the taste.
The frosting was orange in color, but didn't taste any different from the other colored buttercreams they use. Extremely sweet.
Overall, this was a fine, sweet, classic, celebration cake. My third favorite item though, as the others were actually just amazing.
![]() |
| 8" Pumpkin Cheesecake. $39.99. |
Bars
![]() |
| 7-Layer Bar. $3.75. |
7 layer bars, (or 7 layer dips for that matter ...), can be fairly awesome. Or they can be *nearly* awesome, but have that one layer you hate. At least, that is how they seem to go for me.
So I approached this with hesitation, only cutting off a small chunk, because I didn't know what all 7 would be, and I didn't want to waste.
What were the 7 layers? Graham cracker crust, coconut, pecans, chocolate chips, those were all mentioned in the description, and were pretty obvious. But what about the other 3? I spied butterscotch chips. That makes 5 things, but I never found any others. And really, it was only 2 layers: crust and the rest.
Anyway, this was kinda no different from a generic bake sale item. Sweetened coconut, decent distribution of butterscotch chips and chocolate chips, proper size chunks of nuts. Nothing particularly novel about them. They made up the entire topping.
The base was extremely thick more than half the bar really.
![]() |
| Fruit Crumble Bar. $3.75. |
I say I don't really care for bars, but, I do like fruit crumble in other forms, so this was an easy one to give a try.
The top was very generously covered in thick crumble, which, as it is often my favorite part, made me pretty excited. It was .. fine? Not really notable, no interesting flavor (e.g. brown sugar), nothing particularly distasteful about it, but not standout in any way.
Inside was the layer of blueberry filling, much like what you find inside a blueberry danish, rather than juicier and more full bodies like a blueberry pie, crisp, or crumble. I was bored by it.
And at the base, the part I was most skeptical of, since it is where bars usually fail to impress, a shortbread cookie crust, which sounded far more promising than most. However, I didn't get any shortbread cookie element from it, it just was thick, dry, and even more boring.
Overall, there was nothing wrong with this bar exactly, but it was just ... boring.
February 2020
![]() |
| Carrot Cake. |
This was a very, very, very good carrot cake. Wow. Every element was A+.
The carrot cake itself was moist, loaded with shredded carrot and raisins for moisture, loaded with pecans for crunch, and smothered in plenty of rich, sweet, kinda perfect cream cheese frosting. There was tons of frosting, and that was NOT a bad thing.
And then ... what at first I was thrown off by because I hadn't read the description to understand, yes, layers of the praline filing, which was sweet, gooey, and delicious too.
This was unexpected in many ways, and, totally delicious.
![]() |
| OLD-FASHIONED 6-LAYER CHOCOLATE CAKE. |
This one wasn't a winner for me. The cake wasn't particularly moist nor rich chocolatey, the frosting was a fine texture but again, not very special. It was all "fine", but not exciting.
Update Review, January 2019
Sure, I've never been in love with SusieCakes cupcakes before (see my original review, or update review from 2016), but, I was actually *really* craving cupcakes one day, when ...![]() |
| Cupcake Box! |
Thank you, random person who brought in extra cupcakes.
![]() |
| Red Velvet. |
I first went for the red velvet, dressed up a bit for the February holidays (even though it was only January!).
It was better than I remembered, a moist cake, although the flavor of the cake itself was fairly muted. The cream cheese frosting was rich, creamy, and had good cream cheese flavor.
A very decent, standard red velvet cupcake.
![]() |
| Lemon. |
I moved on to the yellow sprinkle topped one, which I worried might be lemon, and, indeed, was. Boo, hiss. I dislike lemon desserts. Luckily, there was one of these cut up and that is what I went for, just a tiny chunk. If it wasn't lemon, or I loved it, I could take the whole one, otherwise, leave it for someone who will appreciate!
The frosting was sweet lovely buttercream, but alas, very strongly lemon flavored. If you like lemon desserts, this was probably great?
![]() |
| Seasonal Special: Banana Chocolate Chip. |
And finally, I went for one that I had no idea what it was. It looked like it might have some kind of chocolate component, I could sorta see something darker in the cake, and it did have the chocolate sprinkles on top. It turned out to be the seasonal special: banana chocolate chip. Doh. I can't say the idea of a banana cupcake excited me, except for the brief moment I thought, "hmm, can I save that for breakfast to have like banana bread? It isn't like it has that much frosting on it, and the frosting is like cream cheese anyway ..."
So, uh, yeah, I saved it for morning, and pulled out alongside a cup of coffee - *after* I had a small bowl of cereal, I'm totally responsible! The frosting was good, the same thick, rich, cream cheese frosting from the red velvet. But the cake? Sure it was moist, sure it was studded with regular size generic chocolate chips, but it was also ... banana. I do not care for banana flavor.
Not the cupcake for me, but well made, and I liked the frosting.
![]() |
| Strawberry. |
Finally, I went for the pink frosted one, not sure if it was the "vanilla pink" or the "strawberry", as both feature vanilla cake and pink buttercream. I believe this was the vanilla pink, as it matches their photo of the vanilla pink, although the frosting just tasted like fluffy sweet buttercream, tasty in a very sweet way, but not strawberry.
The cake was fine, dense, vanilla cake.
I appreciate the generous amount of frosting SusieCakes uses, in particular, it tends to extend down into the cupcake a bit, as if quasi-stuffed.
Update Review, November 2016
![]() |
| Election Day Assortment. |
We had one type of cookie (iced sugar cookie) and 4 types of cupcakes: red velvet, chocolate, vanilla, and flourless chocolate. The flourless chocolate turned out to be amazing.
![]() |
| Frosted Sugar Cookie. $3.25. |
The cookies were simple sugar cookies coated in icing, the same as I had before, just a different themed shape this time. Sweet cookie, sweet icing, fairly classic. Nothing earth shattering, but actually a pretty good sugar cookie.
![]() |
| Red Velvet Cupcake. |
The cream cheese frosting was great though, very cream-cheesy, and there was plenty of it.
Overall, a solid, but standard, cupcake, and since I'm not a big cupcake lover, it was just kinda ok.
![]() |
| Red Velvet (May 2017). |
The decorations, for Easter, were cute though.
![]() |
| Flourless Chocolate Cupcake with Vanilla Buttercream. |
Original Review, January 2015
SusieCakes is, you guessed it, a cake shop, or more accurately, a chain of cake shops, located throughout both Northern and Southern California. They are known for their speciality and custom layer cakes, including "Susie's Famous Southern Red Velvet", but they also make cupcakes, cheesecake, puddings, pies, brownies, and cookies. When you enter the shop, it is hard to look past the cakes though, as most are 4-6 layers, quite impressive looking.The San Francisco location is located in the Marina, right on Chestnut Street. Service is always fairly friendly, and they generally have a sample of one of their specialty cakes out on the counter, which I of course love. The cakes I've tried have all been quite tasty, and I like their cookies, but the cupcakes I didn't like.
I'd love to return though to try their pudding, since I love puddings, and theirs come complete with whipped cream. I also just saw whoopie pies on the menu, which always bring back nostalgia for me. And, if I were ever ordering a full cake, I'd definitely consider SusieCakes, since, as I said, I've liked the cakes.
Cookies
![]() |
| Pumpkin Halloween Sugar Cookie. $3.25. |
I'm not generally one to gravitate towards cookies, but a co-worker brought in assorted decorated cookies for Halloween, and they were too cute not to try. Plus, look at at the icing!
It was a very classic sugar cookie. Nice and soft, not hard and crisp like they sometimes can be. There was shiny, sweet icing on top, a bit crunchy, but I liked that. Sprinkles ... for fun and more sugar.
It was a cute shape, nicely decorated, and was quite tasty for such a simple cookie. I'd eat another (and in fact, went back and had a ghost shaped one later, which was just as tasty). I've seen adorable turkey cookies for Thanksgiving too, so they clearly have fun with seasonal shapes.
It was a large cookie, but $3.25 for such a basic cookie did seem steep, although I guess the decorating time is really what you pay for.
Cupcakes
![]() |
| Mini Vanilla Cupcake with Vanilla Frosting. $20/dozen. |
I love frosting, but there was just way too much of it on this cupcake. It was just sweet, I didn't taste any vanilla, and didn't have a great mouthfeel. It tasted like ... butter. Just butter. Ok, sweet butter. The cake itself was somewhere in-between moist and dry, just kinda there. It also didn't have any flavor.
I did not like this at all.
![]() |
| Mini Chocolate Cupcake with Chocolate Frosting. $20/dozen. |
It was better than the vanilla, but only slightly. Again, the cake was somewhere in-between moist and dry, just kinda there, but at least it had decent chocolate flavor. The frosting was also better, again it had a decent chocolate level, so there was something to it.
But overall, not a winner, and I wouldn't get again.
Cakes
This was actually pretty good, and I bought a slice after trying the sample. So enticing!
The cake was moist and fruity from the pineapple and coconut filling. There was perhaps too much shredded coconut on top, so it somewhat overwhelmed. The buttercream was also quite good, which makes me think that something may have just gone wrong with the batch I had on the vanilla cupcake? I'm not sure how it could be so good on the cake, and so very bad on the cupcake.
The price for this was rather high though, $6.25 for a single slice. Full sized round cakes are also available, $36 for 6", or $49 for 9", or you can go the sheet cake route, $215 for a full sheet, $110 for half, or $75 for a quarter.
![]() |
| Vanilla Celebration Cake. $49 / 9 inch round. |
Update August 2017: Another birthday, another celebration cake. I felt exactly the same way about it. The cake was ... fine, but boring. Not too dry, but not interesting. And the frosting looked far better than it was, it was just sweet, sweet, sweet.
This was ... fine. I liked the ideas behind it, but the fruit itself wasn't particularly flavorful, juicy, or ripe, and the whipped cream and pudding were unremarkable ... as was the plain vanilla cake.
Overall, everything was made well, moist cake, etc, but, it didn't add up to anything special.

























































