Anita - La Mamma del Gelato, Sydney

Update Review, November 2023 Visits

Another trip to Sydney, another excuse to get great gelato.  As much as I love visiting in person, and getting the soft serve froyo with unlimited toppings, or sampling lots of flavors of gelato, the frugal person I am has settled on getting large format containers, and keeping in the freezer to serve myself (basically every afternoon or evening while I'm there ...), rather than paying the much higher per scoop cost.

Caffeinated Flavors. $22 / 500 ML.

My first container was all the caffeinated flavors, my two favorites from my last visit (chocolate mint, and the surprising dairy free dark chocolate), and a new one, tiramisu.

Chocolate Mint (D) (N)

I've had this one before, and it brought me as much joy as last time.  Great mint flavor, swirls of chocolate.  The mint in particular is impressive in intensity.  I'll gladly get this time and again.  My favorite of the chocolate flavors this time.  ****.

Dairy Free Dark Chocolate (DF)

I forgot just how rich this flavor was.  Deep, dark, decadent chocolate.  So decadent.  So rich.  Somehow dairy free.  It is actually *too* much on its own after a few bites, but if you either add a complimentary second flavor of gelato, or whipped cream and strawberries or raspberries, it really is such a winner.  My second favorite of the chocolate flavors this time around.  ***+.

Tiramisu (D)(G)(A)(E)

"A sweet creamy coffee infused gelato base, whipped textured topping and a sprinkle of cocoa."

I like tiramisu.  I like gelato.  So, sure, why not combine them?  

This was good, but not outstanding.  The base gelato was obviously top notch Anita gelato, smooth, rich, creamy.  However, I wanted a stronger coffee base flavor, this was pretty mellow.  It did have decent size hunks of soaked ladyfinger, and cocoa.  Overall, good, but, I'm not sure I would have known it was tiramisu flavor.  ***+.

Non-Chocolate Flavors. $22 / 500 ML.

For my non-chocolate selection, I opted to try two new flavors, and kept my old favorite of white chocolate, coconut, and almonds in the mix.

Cheesecake Crumbles & Passion Fruit (D)(G)(N)

This was definitely a very random pick for me, but, I wanted to try another flavor, and one that didn't have caffeine and wasn't just a plain fruit sorbet, which left me with very few options (Anita is heavy on the chocolate inclusions).  Plus, I do love cheesecake, and I do love fresh passion fruit, so, I had some hope.  After all, Anita tends to delight me.

It was a *very* fruity flavor.  Very sweet.  Very passion fruit heavy.  Passion fruit puree, for sure, but I think possibly made with real fresh passion fruit.  Intense passion fruit flavor.  The cheesecake crumbles were pretty lost among all the passion fruit, but they did deliver a bit of tang from time to time.  

I enjoyed trying this, but didn't want more than a few spoonfuls of it at a tie.  Just too sweet, too intense. I've found it is best with a scoop of something more mellow, or even their tart froyo.  I wouldn't get it again, but if you want intense passionfruit, go for it.  ***.

Pistachio (D)(N)

Last time I had Anita, I had the Halva Pistachio flavor, and liked, but didn't love it, which I suspected was due to the halva.  Before that, I had the white chocolate and pistachio cream flavor, which I enjoyed, but wasn't as heavy in the pistachio.  This time, I wanted to try just the pure pistachio flavor.

It was good.  Strong pistachio, as you'd expect.  Fairly vibrant green, which I think was actually natural.  There are times I want pistachio gelato, and this very much meets the craving.  I love to pair it with Indian desserts.  ***+.

White Chocolate Coconut & Almonds (D) (N)

My final pick was my regular non-caffeinated favorite.  It was exactly as before - nicely sweet from the white chocolate, sorta a light caramelized flavor, grit and texture from coconut and almond bits.  Great on it own, even better with some fresh fruit.  ****.

Frozen Yogurt. $22 / 500 ML.

I also got a tub of the frozen yogurt, which I again appreciated for the tartness, but lamented that it doesn't stay soft serve style for long once I stash in the freezer.  This one really is best to get in person, when you can also add all the great toppings.  But still, great tart frozen yogurt.  ****.

Toppings

Whipped Cream. $3.50.

I added whipped cream to my order on a whim, not necessarily for my gelato, but, because I always like to have some whipped cream on hand for when I need it.  Given the quality of all the other Anita toppings, I assumed this would be fresh made awesome whipped cream.

It came in a paper coffee cup.  It looked to have deflated quite a bit, which let me down.  I suspect this is the kind that comes out of a whipped cream canister, the kind with a charger. Still likely homemade and not a generic supermarket spray can, but, the kind that deflates, not as stable as what pastry chefs tend to use.

It was fine whipped cream, light, fluffy, sweetened.  I don't see the need to get it again, unless I needed whipped cream immediately for something.  ***+.

Granola. $5.50.

If I had visited Anita in person, I would not have gotten the granola, as it looked pretty, well, bo-ring once I saw it.  Not even clusters, not even really toasted, and clearly rock hard raisin pellets.  But ... I ordered for delivery, and didn't know what it would be.  I had hoped it would be like the rest of Anita's toppings, high quality, house made.  Alas, it really was just as it looked.  Dry, lightly toasted, boring granola.  Would not get again.  **+.

Update Review, February/March 2023

Another visit to Sydney, another excuse to order Anita gelato (and frozen yogurt) delivered for my group, and later, for myself. 1L trays are $40 (AUD), and can hold up to 4 different flavors (or, for yogurt, include 6 toppings on the side). These are estimated to be 10 scoops each. The next side down, 500 ML is $22, and can include 3 flavors.

I ordered delivery, via Door Dash, on Sunday afternoon, so that I'd have the gelato ready to go for our part on Monday (a busy day, I didn't want to be stressed dealing with the delivery).  It took an *incredibly* long time to get assigned a Dasher (nearly 2 hours!), and then, when my Dasher was within 5 minutes away and I was headed down to meet them ... I got a call from Door Dash.  My driver had been in an accident (!) and the gelato was "destroyed" (!!).  They offered that I could re-order, but said it would take a full 2+ hours to deliver.  I gave up, and ordered again the next day (it took close to 2 hours that day too). Definitely not the fault of Anita, but, certainly not a good delivery experience.  

Delivery disasters aside, my group (and myself!) enjoyed the gelato.  I ordered more just for myself a few days later.

Chocolatey

Anita offers a bunch of flavors with chocolate either as the base, or as a substantial mix-in.  I've always enjoyed the mix-in flavors before, but find it hard to distinguish between many of them.  As for the chocolate bases, those aren't generally my style of gelato/ice cream, and the same is true at Anita, just, not what I go for.  

This year, I ordered 3 flavors we had tried previously, and 4 new ones.

Chocolate & Hazelnut Cream / Chocolate Almonds & Caramel 
Cookieman (Our Best Seller) / Belgian Chocolate

Chocolate & Hazelnut Cream (D)(N)

While I don't tend to like chocolate bases, and I am not crazy about Nutella like so many others, I was curious to try the Anita version with "hazelnut cream" in a chocolate base.  It was deeply chocolatey, deeply, well, Nutella-y.  Nutella in gelato form, absolutely.  Nutella lovers adored this.  I thought it was too, well, Nutella-y. **+ for me, but **** from the Nutella fans.

Chocolate Almonds & Caramel (D) (N)

This was a new flavor for me, and one that clearly fell into the "I can't tell these apart" category.  It was a flavor full of mix-ins, and a bit of crunch, and a bit of sweetness, but there was no obvious almonds nor caramel.  I liked it, it had some chocolate swirls too, basically like an ice cream sundae all mixed up, but, it didn't really allow any particular element to shine.  Still, quite enjoyable, my favorite of the chocolate lineup in this pan. ****.  I think my third pick of the overall chocolate flavors.

Cookieman (Our Best Seller) (D)(N)(E)

I've had the Cookieman (biscuit, nutella, meringue) before, and I don't love it like others seem to.  It is their best seller, and is always a crowd pleaser, but, I just don't actually tend to like the meringue bits in it (which is odd, because I do love textuers).  Others enjoyed it though.  ***.

Belgian Chocolate (D)

Another flavor I've had before, and another crowd pleaser that isn't really my style.  A lovely, smooth, dark chocolate flavor, but ... yeah, chocolate gelato/ice cream aren't my thing.  Others loved this though, and it was the first flavor to go, again. Well made good chocolate gelato. ***. 

Milk Chocolate Pretzels / Black Forest / Chocolate Mint.

A few days later, just for me, I got a smaller container, filled with one I had liked before (milk chocolate pretzels), and two new ones.

Chocolate Mint (D)

ZOMG, this was so good.  I had expected something like mint chocolate chip, a mint base with chips, or perhaps just a minty-chocolate base.  What it is is a lovely green mint base, loaded with chocolate fudge and bits.  I'd almost call it mint fudge ripple or something.  Such substantial chocolate fudge.

The mint flavor is strong, and tastes "real" if that makes sense.  No medicinal fake mint here.  Excellent mint base.  And then the chocolate fudge ... so good.  Thick, rich, deeply chocolately, and combines perfectly with the mint.

This was a total winner, and I'd gladly get it again and again.  I did find myself wanting some whipped cream for it though.  Still, a top flavor for me, no question.  My second favorite chocolate flavor, just because there was one that was even better.  ****+.

Black Forest (D) (N)

Black Forest sounded like a flavor that could be really good in gelato form.  Basically, kinda like a classic sundae, with the chocolate fudge and cherry components mixed in?  Maybe?  Which I think is what it was, the base seemed to be swirled chocolatey and vanilla, and there was plenty of cherry element, both in a compote like form and I think some whole candied cherries.

This all sounds like good things, and it looked good, but somehow the flavor was just all off for me.  There was an odd taste that I just didn't care for at all.  Was it the kirsch? I am not sure.  I had another serving to try again, but, yeah, I just didn't care for the flavor at all.

**.

Milk Chocolate Pretzels (D) (G) (Sesame)

I have had this one before, and liked it, so this was a repeat for me.  A mild milk chocolate base, with essentially pretzel butter swirled through.  Not chunks of pretzel, but, pretzel butter, which tastes much like cookie butter, in that it is salty and gritty.  I do like it though, and enjoyed this flavor.  I think one best paired with a second flavor as it can be a bit boring on its own though.  ***+.

Dairy Free

Most dairy free flavors, at Anita or elsewhere, are fruity.  And, well, generally aren't what I go for.  I'm all for unnatural sugar, decadence, and cream.  That said, I did have dairy free members of my group, and I know others prefer these style of lighter options anyway, so I picked out 4 dairy free flavors, two of which we'd had before, and two of which were new to me.

Spoiler: I adored one of these.

Dairy Free Dark Chocolate / Coconut / Lemon & Fresh Mint / Mango.

Dairy Free Dark Chocolate

Ok, wow.  Now, you may realize I say I don't care for dairy free, and I don't care for chocolate flavors.  And here I am RAVING about this one.  It was a special request of one of our vegan diners, and I'm so glad she choose this.

I don't know what the base of this is, but, it is chocolate in all the right ways.  So chocolately.  So intense.  And creamy, even though dairy free.  I don't think it uses soy or coconut milk either, I think it really is just ... chocolate sorbet?  Regardless, I've never had anything like it, and I think I prefer it to, well, pretty much any chocolate ice cream or gelato I've ever had.  Seriously.  This was chocolate frozen dessert perfection.

I absolutely adored this, and it went amazingly well with the coconut flavor next to it.  ****+.  The best of all the chocolate flavors.

Coconut

The coconut I have had before, and thought it was good when combined with some other flavors.  I felt the same this time - it was so great with the chocolate.  Strong coconut flavor, very enjoyable.  It was a smooth flavor, no bits of coconut.  I think it would be good on its own with fresh fruit or a sauce drizzled on as well.  ****.

Lemon & Fresh Mint

This was the flavor I got for me, as it was the dairy free one I was most interested in.  It sounded refreshing, and interesting.  Which it was.  A bit minty, a bit lemony, not very sweet.  Basically just a refreshing sorbet, good for a hot day, but not what I tend to go for.  ***.

Mango

Mango we had before and I got for the crowd, as I know there are folks who like fruity ones.  I tried it again, and, yup, fruity.  Sweet and fruity.  Good if you like that sort of thing.  ***.

Nutty / Etc

The next batch of flavor I got was mostly nutty, or otherwise sweet (e.g. white chocolate based).  I got two that I had before and really enjoyed, plus 3 new ones to try out, including a Mardi Gras special.

Salted Caramel & Toffee Cream (D) (N) White Chocolate & Nougat Wafers (D)(N)(G)
White Chocolate Coconut & Almonds (D) (N) Mardi Grass Special (D)(G)

Salted Caramel & Toffee Cream (D) (N)

The salted caramel & toffee I had previously, and I enjoyed it again.  Definitely sweet, but a sophisticated flavor.  I still didn't think it tasted all that much like salt, and would love to see that amped up, but it was a smooth good flavor.  ***+.

White Chocolate & Nougat Wafers (D)(N)(G)

"Hazelnut gelato with matching chocolate sauce and crunchy nougat wafers for a satisfying crunch."

I had several other flavors picked out, but alas, they were sold out, so at last minute I picked this one, not entirely sure what it was.  I was confused when I opened the container to see a chocolately flavor, as I thought this was going to be, well, not chocolately.  

It reminded me of Cookieman actually, which I guess was the bits of nougat wafers being like the meringue?  But I also didn't taste any white chocolate, and it sure seemed to have chocolate in it.  I later found the description on their Instagram, and it made more sense, chocolate sauce as a key ingredient, but it still confused me.  I'm not sure, but, I didn't care for it.  **+.

White Chocolate Coconut & Almonds (D) (N)

This was a new flavor for me, my fall back when the other white chocolate flavors I was excited for were out of stock.  It was sweet, with a white chocolate base, and then gritty, with coconut and almond bits.  I loved the sweetness and all the textures.  You could taste the coconut, but it wasn't as strong as in the dairy free coconut.  The almond was not a noticeable flavor, but I think added to the textures.  I'd gladly get this one again.  ****.

Mardi Gras Special (D)(G)

For mardi gras, the special flavor was Fruit Loops based.  I got it for the group, thinking it would be a hit (don't people love cereal flavors?), but barely anyone even opted to try it.  It went mostly untouched, the only flavor that just didn't draw people in.

I did try it, and, well, it tasted like fruit loops.  It also had full size fruit loops in it.  I don't like fruit loops.  I think you can guess how that meant I felt about this.  Definitely not for me. *+.

Halva Pistachio / Salted Caramel & Toffee Cream  / ???.

For my smaller batch, I ordered one new one to me (halva pistachio), one reliable favorite (salted caramel & toffee cream, reviewed above), and another white chocolate, coconut, and almonds, but ... the later I did not get.  I'm not sure what my container had instead.  I was pretty sad, because I do quite like the white chocolate, coconut, & almonds.

Halva Pistachio (D)(N)(Sesame)

Anita makes a regular pistachio flavor, that I haven't tried, but I decided to go for the even more interesting sounding halva pistachio.

It was obvious which flavor this was, with the slightly green hue, and bits of nuts throughout.  The flavor was, well, pistachio.  A very distinct flavor.  The base was a vanilla gelato, with plenty of the pistachio swirled in, so you did get some bites that were slightly more vanilla, which I liked to break up the strong pistachio.  I did like the crunch from the nuts.  There was also a note of sesame to it, from the halva. So basically, fine pistachio flavor, just a touch more unique with the complimentary halva in it.  It did eat kinda heavy, and I don't think I'd want a big scoop of this, rather, best for pairing with another flavor, or fresh fruit.  ***.

???

I don't know what flavor this was.  It was not the white chocolate, coconut, & almonds that I ordered.  It definitely had chocolate.  That is about all I can say.  I was let down, because I had wanted the other flavor so badly.  That said, this had good mix-ins, and was good gelato, but I still can't even guess what flavor it was.  ***.

Yogurt

The soft serve frozen yogurt (with unlimited toppings!) is what originally drew me in to Anita, and even though its definitely NOT the same without the insane topping lineup, I still got a tray for my group.

Soft Serve Yogurt.

The yogurt was tart and creamy, although quickly lost the lovely soft serve consistency.  It is fine soft serve frozen yogurt, but really is best with lots of toppings. ***.

Toppings

Oh the toppings.  While Anita's gelato flavors mostly have so many mix-ins and interesting flavors that you don't care about adding much for toppings, the yogurt is a neutral base, a blank canvas, to truly adore those toppings.  It is an excuse to devour the incredible toppings, ranging from high quality fresh fruit, to house made candied nuts, to standard candies, to some very unique, and very tasty, sauces.  

For delivery, Anita doesn't offer the full line up of toppings, many of the different candied nuts are not available (only candied almonds are), most of the fresh fruit isn't (only strawberry, or watermelon which I'm allergic to), and many of the candies are also not listed, and I'm not sure why.  What makes candied almonds different from candied macadamias?  Anyway, I still ordered a bunch of toppings to enjoy.  These are pricey, at $5.50 each (or, 6 are included with a 1L froyo).

Lotus Cream. (D) (N) (G)

The Lotus cream I discovered last time, and honestly, couldn't wait to get more of.  I've kinda been dreaming of it since August.

Side note: what I ordered was called "Lotus cream", e.g. Biscoff, but on my receipt, it said "caramel cookies".  Which ... I guess Biscoff cookies are.  I wonder if Anita doesn't actually use Lotus brand?

Anyway, I discovered this last time, and adored it.  I felt the same this time.  Thick, rich, salty, sweet. This batch seemed to have even more big pieces of Lotus biscuit in it, which I'm not sure if I liked more or not.

Great to dunk pretzels in.  Nice drizzled on strawberries.  Obviously good on froyo.  Um, great just by the spoon/lickful.  I'll gladly order this every time.  ****.

Pretzel (D) (G) (Sesame).

I had no idea what "pretzel" sauce would be, but, I was excited to try it.  I thought it might taste a bit like the Lotus one?  

And it did.  Another thick, rich sauce.  Salty, a bit of texture, sorta like, well, liquid pretzel.  Dunking pretzels in here was also good, as was dunking celery sticks.  Just think of it like peanut butter, and you can use it in all those ways.  Equally great by the spoonful, studded with chocolate chips or M&Ms.  I liked it even more than the Lotus cream.  ****+.

Sauces: White Chocolate & Cookies (D) (G)
Chocolate & Meringue (Cookieman) (D) (E) (N) Chocolate & Almonds (D) (N) 

And finally, three more sauces.  The only one of these I'd tried before, the signature Cookieman.

White Chocolate & Cookies (D) (G)

This is basically cookies & cream.  I did like the sweet white chocolate, and it went nicely on my gelato/froyo, but I don't really like the chocolate cookie bits in it, just like I don't really like cookies & cream anthing, nor Oreos.  Just not my thing.  The sweet white chocolate was good though.  ***+.

Chocolate & Meringue (Cookieman) (D) (E) (N) 

I've had this before, and grew to like it.  At first, I was not into the texture from the crunchy meringue (which I know sounds odd, given that I love textures), but once I got used to that element, it no longer bothered me.  I also grew to like the slightly Nutella flavor to it.  This is great drizzled on strawberries, goes wonderfully with whipped cream, and I even like to spread on rice crackers.  Or, you know, frozen yogurt.  ***+.

Chocolate & Almonds (D) (N) 

The least unique perhaps, but nice quality chocolate sauce, lots of bits of almonds.  Perfect for use on ice cream / gelato sundaes.  I also enjoyed dunking bananas in it.  ***+.

Update Review, August 2022

This year, my visit to one of my favorite dessert places in Sydney, Anita, took a bit of a different turn.  While historically I've always visited in person, opting for their tart soft serve frozen yogurt rather than the gelato, because, um, their topping selection is just unparalleled, which, you've hopefully read about in my prior reviews (if not, stop, and go read those - below - first!).

This visit was different as I made a large catering order, for delivery.  Yup, major risk, delivery gelato?  My first time ever doing such a thing, and I hoped it wouldn't turn into a disaster.  I was ordering for a large group, about 45 people, so I ordered several of Anita's largest 1L catering tubs, along with some toppings, via Uber Eats.

Catering Bag.

My order came in fairly fancy Anita branded bags with silk handles.  I was happy to report that gelato was still very solid when it arrived, no drama.

Yogurt

"Give yourself a low-fat treat, and try out our refreshing range of completely addictive frozen yogurts. Take a bite, topped with fresh fruit, sweet syrup, high quality chocolate, or Anita’s unique home-made jams."

I was mostly ordering gelato for my group, but, I couldn't resist adding on a tub of the soft serve yogurt as well.  That said, I knew it wouldn't be quite the same, as the magical part about Anita's soft serve yogurt, at least for me, is the amazingly good toppings.  Yogurt is available in just one flavor, tart.  Again, it is usually all about the toppings (which are unlimited, and include refills, when you are at the shop).

Soft Serve Yogurt, 1L. $36.75.

The yogurt held up better than I expected for delivery, the styrofoam container did its job well.  It was soft but not melty, and really, just as good as fresh from the machine.  With no toppings on it, I also had the chance to really taste, and appreciate, the base yogurt.  It is good, tangy, not very sweet, rather classic tart.  Smooth, creamy, soft yogurt, no icy consistency.  

Just, very good, simple, tart yogurt.  I don't think I've had better elsewhere, even without toppings to jazz it up.  ****.

That said, the yogurt tub did come with my choice of 6 toppings included in the price, although many of my favorite Anita toppings were not listed as options (e.g. the mango, berries besides strawberries, the sauces, candied macadamias, freckles, and more).  Additional toppings are available (for the yogurt or gelato) for $5.50 for a small container.  These came in small little containers on the side.

Gelato

"Taste the creamy goodness of Anita’s unforgettable ice creams. Whether you’re in the mood for mint-chocolate-chip or could kill for coconut-lime, enjoy fabulous flavour and a smooth, rich cream base. You only live once. Go on, give it a go!"

Anita is primarily a gelato shop, even if I always visit for the yogurt.  They make 150 or so flavors that rotate through, although many of the top sellers are always available.  I selected 10 for my group, some chocolately, some fruity, some nutty.  It was hard narrowing down to just 10, and I'd gladly try many more flavors.

The texture of all of them was absolutely perfect, smooth, airy, rich, all at once. 

1L Gelato: Chocolatey.  $36.75.
Cookieman, Belgian Chocolate, Chocolate Almonds & Caramel, Milk Chocolate Pretzels.

Every 1L pan of gelato can fit up to 4 flavors.  For the first tub, I opted for all chocolatey ones, so they'd blend together ok.  I got two of these, and they were the first finished.  People obviously like chocolate.

I'll admit, I'm not entirely sure which was which here, besides the obvious dark Belgian chocolate.  I tried them all.

The Belgian chocolate was my least favorite, but I also don't tend to really like chocolate ice cream/gelato.  **+.  I got that as an easy crowd pleaser, and, it was indeed one of the first finished.

I also wasn't a huge fan of the Cookieman, which I know is Anita's best seller, but, the crispy bits of meringue mixed in just weren't really for me.  I love textures and mix-ins, but, for some reason, this one just doesn't do it for me. ***.

The other two, chocolate almonds & caramel and milk chocolate pretzels I liked - they too had a lot of textures and goodies mixed in, and all had mild chocolate flavor,  Sweet but not too sweet, mostly just enjoyable flavors.  But, alas, I really do not know which was which in this photo.  ****.

1L Gelato: Fruity. $36.75.
Mascarpone Ricotta & Strawberry, Mango (DF), Coconut (DF).

Next I did a tub of fruity flavors, including two non-dairy, vegan options.  I only selected 3 as the fruity flavors were the least interesting, and we didn't have that many vegans in the group.

The mango was too sweet and fruity for my mood, the coconut was fine but boring compared to the other options.  ***, but, not really my thing.

The mascarpone ricotta & strawberry was the one I was most interested in trying, as I like mascarpone and ricotta, but don't generally like strawberry ice cream ... but love strawberry desserts and strawberries *on* my ice cream.  I did like the slightly savory quality from the ricotta, and pockets of cheese, but the berry was more fruity than I really cared for.  Still, I was quite glad to try it.  ***.

1L Gelato: Nutty/Creamy.  $36.75.
 Macadamia Cream, Salted Caramel & Toffee Cream, White Chocolate & Pistachio Cream.

My final tub I did nutty/cream options.  I only picked 3 so I'd have more of each, but it was hard to narrow this down.  This was the tub I was most excited for, and I got multiples of it, as I expected it to go fast.

The macadamia cream was good, I liked the texture from the macadamias, and, well, I like macadamias.  It was macadamia heavy, so you need to be in the mood for macadamias.  It felt a touch boring though.  I think this would be best with some fresh fruit on top, or perhaps alongside a chocolate flavor.  With some fresh mango I think it would be amazing.  ***+.

Next the ever trendy salted caramel ... with toffee cream.  This one was just too sweet for me on its own.  It paired well with a certain type of dessert (I did a few days later when I had some bread pudding and that worked nicely, I suspect a molten chocolate cake would work too), but, on its own, it was just too sweet.  Not cloying sweet, it was a complex sweet, but, sweet nonetheless.  *** on its own, **** as a pairing.

And finally, my favorite of the bunch, the white chocolate & pistachio cream.  Bits of texture from the pistachios, sweetness from the white chocolate, a well rounded flavor that ate fine on its own.  I'd get this again.  ***+.

Toppings

Anita's toppings are definitely part of what initially drew me in years ago, as they are all incredibly high quality, mostly house made, and just perfect with the soft serve yogurt.  I don't think they make as much sense with the gelato though.

My soft serve yogurt tub came with 6 included, but you can add extras, or get them for the gelato, for $5.50 for each small container, which seems incredibly pricy for what they are, particularly given that they are unlimited on the yogurt in the shop ...

Strawberries.  $5.50.

I partially originally fell in love with Anita due to the fresh fruit toppings for the soft serve yogurt.  Seriously, some of the best mango and kiwi I've ever had.  Top notch berries too.  I know it was winter, but, strangely, the only fruit available to order was strawberries or watermelon, the later of which I'm allergic to, so, just strawberries it was.

The berries were not particularly ripe, and were kinda sad looking, pale and white.  Nothing like the glorious fruit from my previous visits. **+.

Cookieman. $5.50.

While I've never been that into the signature Cookieman (gelato or sauce), I know it is Anita's top seller and big attraction, so I got it for my group.  As a reminder, this is a mix of meringue, biscotti and Nutella ... basically, rich, indulgent, chocolately, and full of texture.

It did go quite well on the gelato, and everyone who had it really liked it.  People were most impressed by the texture of course, from all the unexpected bits of meringue and biscotti.  ***+.

Lotus Cream.  $5.50.

The only other sauce available for delivery, besides jams, was lotus cream.  While it wouldn't be my top choice, it was the only option, so I got it.

Um, zomg, this was delicious.  I know people go crazy for "cookie butter", but I didn't think I was one of them.  Turns out, I am?  Rich, sweet, caramelized flavor, slightly gritty texture ... um, it was just delicious.  Delicious on the frozen yogurt, delicious by the spoonful (I mean, I didn't do that, surely ...), and, I think it would be great spread on waffles.

I'm glad I tried it, but, danger, danger, I am pretty sure I could do some damage with this!  ****.

And yes, I immediately went home and tried to find where I could buy some of this.  I can imagine so many usages ... basically, in place of peanut butter, on just about, well, anything.

Dark and White Chocolate Drops. $5.50 each.

Anita doesn't make the chocolate drops themselves, and actually, my hotel had the same ones (white, milk, dark) in the breakfast buffet, but I do like them, whatever brand they are, they seem decent quality, creamy and smooth.  ****.  

Candied Almonds. $5.50.

Candied nuts are another component I always loved at Anita, and again, for some reason, the regular large lineup of a variety of candied nuts (and, in particular, the macadamias!), was not available for delivery.  Just candied almonds, so I got them.

They were ridiculously candied, with a thick candy shell, super sweet, stuck together.  Decadent as almonds can be.  I loved them, but they were definitely too sweet to put on the gelato.  They went fine on the tart yogurt, or, uh, by the handful into my mouth.  ****.

Edible Chocolate Spoon! $0.25.

In addition to little gelato cups and spoons, I also got a few edible spoons.  Yes, edible spoons!

The idea of edible spoons is interesting, and I was curious how they'd do this.  Chocolate seemed like it would snap too easily, even with soft gelato.  Would these be more like ... biscuits?  I had no idea.

The answer is ... I truly do not know what these were.  They weren't really cookie/biscuit like.  But, they were solid, um, kinda what chocolate cardboard would taste like?  They were kinda bitter.  I didn't care for them at first, but, they kinda grew on me.  A far more savory item than I expected  I'm still not sure how I felt about these, and I think they'd be kinda annoying to use with gelato anyway, but they were interesting to try.

***?.

Update Review, March 2020

Another year, another trip to Sydney, another visit  to Anita the first chance I got (I had to wait until the weekend as it is a bit far from where I was working and staying).  Luckily for me, Sunday was a warm sunny day, and it was perfect "ice cream weather".

If you haven't heard me rave, you should start with my original review first, where I give you the run down of Anita glory, and my subsequent update review as well.

I headed to Anita with glee.  I rounded the corner, it came into view, and I nearly ran.  I was so excited.  The shop was not busy, which was great, no pressure to decide fast.

I tried two gelatos (I still really do intend to get gelato there sometime!), and they were both fun and unique - salted peanut chocolate and popcorn - both sweet and savory and full of texture, but ... I couldn't do it.  I needed an epic froyo.

Toppings.

The toppings lineup looked as glorious as ever.  All the sauces. All the fruits.  All the candy.  All the crunch.  #allTheThings.

Now, one note.  Something *has* changed at Anita.  You do still select a size (small, regular, large) and it does still come with unlimited toppings, and they really will load them on.  But ... you used to also get free *refills* of toppings, until your yogurt was gone.  I'm guessing people abused this, as, alas, it is no more.  You can however pay $1 for another round of toppings, which, given the caliber of their toppings, really is a fantastic deal.

I went in with a plan, following exactly my notes from last time, modifying only given availability.

Small with salted peanut sauce and hazelnut crunch in base
fresh strawberry, fresh kiwi, macadamia nuts, candied almonds, mango sauce, flake, wafer.  $9.

I was hoping for a new chocolate based sauce, but alas, same line up.  Salty peanut sauce was my sauce choice, as the others have just been too sweet, and I do love the salty peanut sauce.   Also, per my discovery last time, mango sauce.  The salty peanut went in the base, the mango drizzled on top.

Of course I wanted as much fruit as possible, and went for kiwi and strawberry, because, alas, no mango in season.

Then, nuts, you know, "protein".  Macadamias because they are just so good in Australia, and candied almonds, because they are fantastic at Anita.

Also in the base I added hazelnut crunch, per my notes, to have a crunch item.  And rather than 100s and 1000s, I went for flake sprinkled on top for a touch of chocolate.  I finally accepted the offer of a wafer cone chunk.

And there it was.  Lovingly assembled, with a staff member who genuinely seemed to mean it when she said "what else?!"

It was a total success.

The fruit was absolutely fabulous, as always.  I don't understand how their fruit is so good, but the strawberry and kiwi were both just excellent.  I adored them.  The mango drizzle was a nice fruity compliment as well, although I wanted a bit more.  Definitely the right move to leave off the heavier sauces on top.  The flake was nice, but basically just for looks, I didn't really taste it.  Next time I'd either do 100s & 1000s again for the slight crunch (and look!), or try a larger crunch/chocolate, like the little chocolate pearls.  Or the hazelnut crunch on top.

I loved both kinds of nuts, as always.

The wafer was ... fine.  A wafer.  Not really my thing, but the branding was pretty awesome, and it did look great perched on top.  I'd leave it off in future.

Salty Peanut Sauce in base

The salted peanut sauce in the base was chunky, sweet, salty, and horrible for me, but I really like it.  Definitely best at the base, so I could mix in as I wanted, and it didn't take over everything.  The hazelnut crunch unfortunately got totally lost in it, so next time I'd still like another crunch element, but one that won't get lost - perhaps the chocolate pearls?  Or even chocolate drops or freckles?  Still, peanut sauce a definite winner.

Overall, yup, everything here a success, I loved it all, just some slight tweaks to make it even *better* next time!

Update Review: October 2019

Another visit to Sydney, and another mandatory stop at Anita.  The weather this trip was the coldest I've ever experienced in Sydney, even compared to when I was there in July, so ice cream, gelato, and froyo weren't quite as appealing as usual, but, I still needed to go to at least my favorites.  Anita is near the top of that list.  You should start with my original review first.

Overwhelming, and delicious.

The experience at Anita is overwhelming.  There is no question about that.  Between all the incredible looking gelato options, to the plethora of froyo toppings, and the promise of unlimited refills on toppings, it is easy to just stand there gawking.

As always, I tried a few gelatos, and they were good, but, the toppings bar for froyo was just too amazing to pass up.  So, ridiculous froyo creation it was, and yes, I went for topping refills.

I love it so much.

Glorious Sauces.

The warm sauce lineup had some repeats from my previous visit, plus a few new additions, 9 total.

The Nutella based lineup was 3 strong: Nutella & almond, Loacker (Nutella & waffles), and the signature Cookieman (Nutella & meringue).

The only chocolate base was "Oreo", dark chocolate sauce with Oreo bits.  "Hershey's" seemed to be white chocolate with chocolate bits (biscuit or just chocolate? I think like the cookies and cream bar, so, biscuits?).

The rest were sweeter, white chocolate or caramel based, including Lotus (caramel biscuits) and Nougat & cornflake.  Finally, two nutty options, Peanut and  Salted cashew.

This section also had a few sauces in squirt bottles, peanut butter, pistachio, maple syrup, and sour cherry.

Other fruit based sauces were elsewhere in the toppings bar.

Toppings Part 2: Fruits, Nuts, Biscuits, Chocolate.

The lineup continued, an overwhelming array of choices, with fresh fruit (kiwi, strawberry, grapes, pineapple, watermelon), nuts (whole macadamias, candied almonds, candied cashews, walnuts), and some sweet options (wafer bars, both white and dark, Freckles, both white and dark, chocolate flake, and hazelnut crunch).

Oh my. 

I was sad to see no mango, but, it wasn't in season, so that is likely good quality control on their part.  No blueberries either.  I did have a moment of pause due to the proximity of the watermelon (severe allergy ...), but they have individual scoops for everything, and ... uh, I took a calculated (likely foolish, I know), risk.

Toppings Part 3: Candy & Sauces.

The final section is mostly candy and smaller items, plus some fruit sauces.

Gummy candy (gummy bears, sour soda bottles, sour sharks, marshmallows, jelly beans), chocolate (dark, white, milk disks, hard chocolate candies, crispy chocolate pearls), a few healthier items (shredded coconut, raisins, granola, chopped almonds, banana chips), and the fruit sauces (mango, and a few berry sauces), and of course, basics like sprinkles (er, 100s & 1000s).

Not shown is the wafers you can have thrown on at the end too.

Small ... with ... #allTheToppings.

I went in with a plan to be reasonable, knowing I could get refills, but .... with all those toppings in front of you, and the staff repeating, over and over, "What else?!" "Anything more?", it is hard to stick to it.  So yes, I wound up with ... many things.

I had not one, not two, but three sauces, even though I had made notes to my future self to *not* do that: Nougat & cornflake, Oreo, and Salted Peanut, the last of which I had put on the base.

I had two types of fruit, kiwi and strawberry, both on top, and more strawberries on the base.

I had three types of chocolate - dark and white chocolate Freckles perched around the edges, and chocolate flake in the base.

I had three kinds of nuts - whole macadamias and candied almonds on top, hazelnut crunch in the bottom.

And sprinkles.  Always sprinkles.

It was, as always, ridiculous looking.  And so very beautifully assembled.  The staff here have such patience, between everyone requesting a slew of gelato samples, to everyone who picks froyo adding a slew of toppings, they do it all with a smile, with encouragement, and, they really do seem to care to arrange it all nicely.

Now, stepping back, you'll notice a few things.  My previous reviews said to lay off the extensive sauces, although I did encourage myself to try a sauce on the bottom, and I definitely recommend that again.  And guess what?  My past self was right: lay off the sauces!!!

The Nougat & cornflake sauce was just sweet, sweet, sweet.  It didn't go that well with the tart yogurt, and turned out to just be way too much for me.  It was generously applied, and a fun sauce, just, not right for this application.  I also wasn't really into the kinda soggy cornflake bits.

The Oreo sauce I really disliked.  I wanted a chocolate sauce, and that seemed to be my only real option (besides the Nutella based ones).  It wasn't really that dark, not like a fudge, more like a runny chocolate sauce.  And, I don't like Oreo really, so the Oreo bits weren't for me.

Future self: leave these off!  The sauces are awesome, but just don't go with this froyo.  Only add a chocolate sauce if there is one you actually want!

On the positive sauce side though: the salty peanut sauce.  Now this was *amazing*.  Creamy, sweet and salty, and loaded with whole peanuts.  It did go well with the froyo, and I liked having it in the base, as I could dunk my final spoonfuls of froyo in it, scrape it out when everything ran out and I wanted "one more bite", and dip strawberries in it.  Definitely, definitely recommended.

Moving on: the fruit!  Both the strawberries and kiwi were excellent, juicy, ripe, flavorful, and far better than they looked.  And, a really nice complimentary flavor with the tart froyo.  Highly recommend, will continue to focus on the fruit.  I did have strawberries in the bottom, which I think I'd skip in the future - I liked how they were coated in the peanut sauce, but, they got slightly frozen under the froyo, and seem like a waste of bowl space, since I can add those on later when I refill.  So, future self: no fruit in bottom, but lots on top.  And refills.

Next up: the nuts!  The candied almonds really are fantastic, very, very candied, but, much like the sauces, just incredibly sweet and sticky to have on the froyo.  I love them, for the crunch in particular, but, they were not what I wanted mixed in.  I knocked them off and saved them for the end, and I really did enjoy them that way.  The macadamias were great, quality nuts, whole, and good crunch.  They went well with everything.  And finally, the hazelnut crunch in the bottom - this doesn't *really* count as a nut, more like candy, but, I liked having that for more texture, and the bottom seemed like the right place for it.  Maybe on top?  So, future self: yes to some kind of crunch (more on that later), yes to macadamias, and yes to candied almonds, but, remove them immediately (or get them as refill)?

Moving into the candy layers.  The 100s & 1000s - of course I loved those.  Crunch, color, fun!

Another Side View.

Here you can see another side, where the Freckles were concentrated, along with more kiwi.

I do really love Freckles, both white and dark, but, much like the candied almonds, I struggled with them on here.  They were large, sweet, and a bit overwhelming.  But I loved them.  I knocked them off too, and finished them after, and was quite gleeful, like a little kid who just discovered one more leftover piece of Halloween candy when they thought they were out.  Note to self?  Same thing: leave them off, or, add as refill to have at end, or knock off immediately.  Or consider the smaller chocolate drops?

The last (I think?) element I had in the initial round was chocolate flake, also in the base.  I appreciated the chocolate, and it went great with the peanut sauce in the base.  I'd get this again, either in the base, or on top.

Oh yeah, the froyo.  It is a tart style, creamy but a bit icy, basically, classic froyo consistency, not too sweet, seems like good quality.  But I wouldn't want just a cup of it.

It is pretty clear to me that I know what to do differently next time: one sauce, in the base, with some kind of crunch or chocolate (hazelnut crunch, chocolate pearls, chocolate flake).  Fruit mostly on top, with some kind of crunch or chocolate there too?  Consider the candied almonds and Freckles carefully, do add the macadamias.

And then ... refills.  Because, yes, they really do allow unlimited refills (while your yogurt remains).

Refill: Strawberry, Kiwi, Mango Sauce.

My refill round was a great success.  I knew exactly what I wanted: MORE FRUIT.  I was on a sugar high at this point, and wanted the fresh, juicy things to compliment the remainder of my froyo.  My only real options were strawberry and kiwi, but I liked them both, so, no worries (pineapple and grapes are not exciting to me!).  I mentioned the lack of mango, and the server encouraged me to get the mango sauce.  I was going to resist, because I didn't want more crazy sweet, but he said it was really fantastic, house made.

And he was right.  The mango drizzle worked really well, sweet, fruity, complimentary.  I'd get this again, perhaps on top initially, instead of the sweet rich sauces.  Or just with refills.  Either way works.

By the time I got to the very base, and scraped up every last bit of the salty peanut sauce, I was quite pleased, on a sugar high, and totally about to go into massive food coma.  And yes, then I ate my candied nuts and Freckles, which ... uh ... did not help things.

Still, <3.

Decaf Long Black.

It wasn't particularly warm out, and I was really craving coffee, so I also got a decaf long black, to warm up a bit while I ate the cold froyo, and have something to offset the sweet.  I had it black.

It was fine, a fairly strong coffee, and I sorta wished I asked for more hot water to mellow it a touch.  But the strong bitterness is exactly what I needed with my pile of sugar, and I definitely would want a black coffee alongside in the future.

Original Review: June 2019

La Mamma del Gelato.  Anita.  Gelato by Mama Anita.  I'm not entirely sure what the locals actually call this place.  I just know that in Sydney, there is plenty of competition for quality gelato, and Anita is among the top.

La Mamma?

The story behind Anita is all about family, a lady who liked to make frozen treats for friends and family, using her own housemade jams that were "famous" in their own right.  Her son started selling it, first at a local market, and then at a parlour, and now, a chain.

Gelato is the focus, with 150 kinds offered on rotation, including some dairy free sorbets, lower fat and lower sugar options too.  All use very premium mix-ins.  They also make frozen yogurt, soft serve, with an incredible array of toppings, mostly homemade as well.

As an ice cream fan, it didn't take me long to seek out Anita, although, to be honest, it was only about halfway down my list, since Sydney has so many amazing soft serve places, and that is more my style.

I visited on a hot day in Sydney.  Quick summary?  I'll be back!  Many, many times. (And, already did return!)

Froyo Victory #1. February 2019.

My first visit was in February.  I ... was overwhelmed by the experience.

Because, OMG, the toppings.

That is what I have to say about the experience.  The toppings, wowzer.  Incredible.  More on this soon.

I also tried several flavors of gelato, and agree, it is among the best in Sydney.

Froyo #2: March 2019.

When I returned to Sydney the very next month, in March, Anita was near the top of my list of places to return to.  I didn't make it early in my trip, but my last Sunday, after a rainy Saturday spent inside working, the sun came out, the temperature rose to 80°, and I made my way to Anita.

I thought I might get gelato, to try something different, and I did try a couple flavors and they were great, but, again, those toppings.  I had no choice.  I had to go for froyo.

Setting

I visited the location in Sydney in Chippendale, although they also have a location near Bondi beach.

Gelato Counter.

The setup is fairly standard, long counter with gelato, long line of folks waiting to order, served one by one.  I found out later that if you want yogurt, you can actually just go to the other side.

There is seating both inside and out on the sidewalk, although I always choose to go sit in the park in the sun.  The park is literally right across the street, a single lane low traffic street, so fairly ideal for me, I get my sun, *and* I can dash back inside for my unlimited topping refills.  Yeah, more on that soon.

Gelato

Anita is mostly known for the gelato, for both the quality, and the flavor variety.  Gelato takes up the majority of the shop space, with stunning displays.

Of course they allow samples, which nearly every person entering indulged in.  I was impressed with all the flavors I tried, the texture and consistency was just perfect, so very creamy.

Salted Cashew / White Chocolate & Hazelnut / Chocolate Cheesecake / Mascarpone, Ricotta, & Strawberry (back row)
Pistachio / Belgian waffle & Dulce de Leche / Pavlova & Mix Berry / Cookieman (front row).

The gelato lineup is very visually appealing.  I like how the front row is stacked higher, garnished with drizzles, more elaborate.  The back row is cleaner lines, but no less appealing flavors.

The first section had the best sounding flavors.  I wanted to try them all.  The most popular flavor is "Cookieman", with chocolate, hazelnuts, biscuits and swirls of meringue, but I heard people ordering just about every flavor.  And of course, you could sample.

From this section, I managed to narrow my choices down to only 2 to try:

• Belgian waffle & Dulce de Leche: The first one I tried.  I was impressed with the creamy texture, but I didn't really know what was "waffle" about it, no chunks of waffle, no flavor of waffle.  It was very sweet from the dulce de leche well integrated throughout.  Too sweet for me.
• Cookieman: This was good.  It had a lot going on inside, obviously.  I loved all the crunch, the chocolate, the nuts, etc.  But really, it is what inspired me that while the gelato was good, I really do adore mix-ins, and thus, I should get something with toppings.

My second visit, this section had a bunch of new flavors (and, some repeats of course):

• Panna Cotta & Lotus Cream: I really liked this flavor.  The lotus was a fascinating flavor, subtle, slightly floral almost.  I was fascinated by the flavor, and I really enjoyed it.  I would be happy getting a cone of this.

White Chocolate & Pistachio Cream / Kinder Bueno / Ferror Rocher / Chestnut & Hazelnut Cream.  (back row).
Vanilla Madagaskar / Chocolate with Almonds & Caramel / Oreo Cookies / Chocolate (front row).

I tried only one from here, since I had decided against gelato, but I was curious about the chestnut and hazelnut cream too ...

• White Chocolate & Pistachio Cream: I sometimes adore pistachio gelato, and I picked this over the simple pistachio as it had a great layer of pistachio cream on top.  I was again impressed with the texture, and the flavors were strong.  It was good.

Rafello / (unsure) / (unsure)  (back row)
Dark Chocolate (dairy free) / Coconut / Lemon & Fresh Mint / Watermelon & Fresh Mint (front row).

The next section of flavors was far more boring to me, which I was glad, as there were too many choices as it was.

The lemon & fresh mint was very popular, people seemed to appreciate a refreshing option.

Peanut Butter & Cheesecake / Black Forest / Salted caramel XX / Sugar Free Hazelnut / Coffee Sugar Free (back row)
Strawberry & banana / Raspberry (front row).

In this section, I was interested in the peanut butter cheesecake flavor, but again, I had decided on froyo, so I didn't want to be greedy.  Black Forest looked particularly good too.

On my second visit, the peanut butter option was chocolate peanut butter, and I tried it. It was pretty fantastic, with thick chocolate ganache on top, creamy peanut butter, and just tons of flavor.  Soooo rich.  Very, very good.

It was nice that they had sugar free options as well.

Frozen Yogurt & Toppings

While the majority of the space is filled with gelato, and 90% of people were getting gelato, I knew, from my research, that Anita offered something else too.

Frozen yogurt.  Froyo.  Plain, soft serve frozen yogurt.  Now, why would I get frozen yogurt, when I'm saying the gelato was so good?  And particularly, why only when they make one base flavor of frozen yogurt?

Because, toppings.  Oh the toppings.

The model at Anita is not something I've seen before.  Unlimited toppings (and bottommsings).  With refills.

It is not self-serve, but they explain that they'll put toppings on bottom, then the soft serve, then more toppings. And, as long as you are there and have more yogurt, you can come back for more.  More of whatever, it doesn't need to be the same thing you had previously.

Um, ok, awesome.

And the toppings.  OMG.  The best topping lineup I've ever seen anywhere in my life.  Mostly all housemade.  Seriously high quality.

I'm not sure if you could, or would want to, add these toppings to gelato.  The pricing is such that for gelato you pick a # of scoops, and for frozen yogurt, you pick a size.  No topping price listed, and its clearly intended for the yogurt.

I adored the toppings.

Side note: On my first visit, they also had soft serve acai sorbet, which follows the frozen yogurt model as well, but they didn't have it on my second visit, much to the dismay of the group behind me.

Toppings, Part 1: Syrups / Sauces / Nuts / Fruit / Chocolate.

I won't enumerate all the toppings.  There were too many.

The first section contained squirt bottles of syrups, ranging from sour cherry to peanut butter, with a slew of other fruity or sweet options along the way, 8 total options.

Normally I'd be into the syrups, but there was something better next: sauces.  9 choices here, including Cookieman sauce (milk chocolate with hazelnuts, meringue, etc), plus several each with white, milk, or dark chocolate bases, some with nuts, others with coconut, biscuits, etc.  And a cookie butter option of course.

Then we get into nuts!  But not just boring sliced nuts.  Nope, candied nuts (almonds or cashews), even whole macadamias.  These are not cheap boring nuts.  The candied ones are candied in house.

The fruits looked incredibly vibrant and fresh, including strawberries, mango, kiwi, pineapple, watermelon, etc.

Then, chocolate based things, white or dark chocolate candies, and even chunks of both milk chocolate and white chocolate Tim Tams.

But this was just the first section.

More Toppings! Dried Fruit / Candy / Nuts / Crunch.

Next up was more standard toppings, including white chocolate, milk chocolate, or dark chocolate chips, all kinds of candy including gummy candy, chewy candy, chocolate candies, jelly beans.

Dried fruit, granola, and non-candied nuts for the healthy types.  Cereal, crunchy things, crumbles of different varieties.  Fruity coulis and jams.

Something for everyone here.

Small Frozen Yogurt with
Cookieman Sauce White Chocolate, Coconut and Peanuts Sauce /
Fresh Mango / Candied Walnuts / Candied Almonds / 100s & 1000s (top)
Fresh Mango / Fresh Kiwi / Candied Walnuts / Candied Almonds / White Chocolate Freckles (bottom).
$8. (February).

Um.  Yeah.  This was a small.  A SMALL.  The smallest size.  Oh, wow.

I felt a bit like a kid in a candy store.  Sure, at Pinkberry they say "as many toppings as fit", but they only really give you ~3 things, and they look annoyed as they ask what you'd like.  Here, my server said, "Ok, what do you want on bottom?  I'll put toppings on top too, but let's start with the bottom."  I asked for mango and kiwi, and she was like "and what else?  Pick as much as you want!".  So I added both types of candied nuts to add, uh, protein, and crunch.  And some white chocolate freckles, cuz they looked fun.

Then she went and filled it up with frozen yogurt.  My eyes went wide, I'm sure.  I have no idea what the medium or large would be like!

"Now what would you like? Pick as much as you want!"  I started with sauces, asking for Cookieman on one side, since every review I read raved about it, and also selecting the white chocolate coconut because I wanted something sweet and creamy to balance the tart frozen yogurt.  The mango looked so good, I asked for more of that too.  And more of the candied nuts, saying, "pick your favorite of the candied nuts", and she said they were both good, so she added both kinds.  I also opted for 100s & 1000s, because, come on, it needed to look a bit more ridiculous, right?

She offered again, "and what else?"  I declined more at this point, as it looked pretty full and indulgent.  "Its you first time right?", she asked.  When I responded affirmatively, she eagerly told me that I could keep coming back up for more toppings as I ran out.

Mind blown, I handed over my $8, and went outside to devour.

The yogurt base was good, but it is frozen yogurt, so not as creamy and rich as soft serve ice cream, and a bit tart.  But, good enough frozen yogurt.

And yes, I *could* taste it under all the toppings.  I loved most of my toppings, but I'd clearly change some things next time.

I was not as in love with the Cookieman as the masses seem to be.  It was good, don't get me wrong, but the meringue crunch just wasn't really for me.  And I'm less excited about chocolate-hazelnut that most it seems (sorry, Nutella).  I still finished all the sauce, but, I'd pick something else next time.

The white chocolate coconut sauce was sweet, creamy, and served its purpose, but was fairly easily lost among everything else on there.  I'd consider getting it again, but likely would try something else.

The fresh fruit was incredible.  The mango and kiwi were soooo ripe, so juicy, so fresh.  Clearly high quality fruit.  I adored the fruit.  Next time, more fruit.

The candied almonds I did like quite a bit, the crunch factor was awesome, and they were heavily candied, which got to be a bit much with all my other toppings, but that isn't their fault.  I'd get these again.

The candied cashews however weren't as successful.  I think this is just me and my random disliking of cashews that seems to happen from time to time.  I never knew when it will strike.

The white chocolate freckles were totally unnecessary, just sweet lower end confection, hiding in the base.  I'd skip those in the future.  Of course I loved the 100s & 1000s.

#ooph.

I'd like to say that I had restraint and didn't finish that monster.  Particularly given that I might have had another ice cream earlier in the afternoon (shh!).  But.  I finished every. last. bite.  At least I didn't go back for more toppings?

I'd definitely get the frozen yogurt again, but, I have some modifications to make.

I'd still get 1-2 sauces (or maybe syrups), but I'd pick different ones.  Absolutely I'd get tons of fresh fruit on bottom and top.  Kiwi, mango, strawberry for sure.  And I'd go back for refills of those.

I like having crunch, so the candied almonds were nice, but I think I'd go for macadamias next time, not candied.  With the sauces, no need for the extra sugar toppings.  I might add white chocolate chips or some of the other crunchy toppings though, for more texture.

Or maybe I'd get gelato?

Small Frozen Yogurt with:
 Snickers Sauce / White Chocolate, Pecans and Walnuts Sauce / Sour Cherry Syrup /
Fresh Mango / Fresh Kiwi / Whole Macadamias / Pecan Crunch /  100s & 1000s (top)
Fresh Mango / Fresh Kiwi / Whole Macadamias / Hazelnut Crumbles (bottom).
$8. (March).

My next visit, I read my notes, and went prepared to make better decisions.

I still opted for two sauces, different ones this time, one on each side, one chocolate based, one white based, and, at last minute, added a syrup drizzle too.

I still opted for fresh fruit on top and bottom, as that was clearly a highlight, and 100s & 1000s because I can't resist.  I swapped over to macadamias instead of candied nuts, and added a couple random crunchy toppings (hazelnut crunch on bottom, pecan crunch on top) ... whatever those were.

This creation was just as epic and ridiculous and overwhelming as my previous.  And, yes, more successful.

The white chocolate pecan sauce I could taste this time, unlike the white chocolate coconut from last time, but I found myself not caring for it that much - it was very sweet, and the sweetness didn't compliment the tart style of yogurt very well.  I wouldn't get it again.

The Snickers sauce was great though, crazy rich, thick, chocolately sauce.  When I later added strawberries, it went great with them, and the macadamias too.  I'd get this again, or try more chocolate based sauces ...

The sour cherry syrup was fine, but a touch too sweet, I think mostly due to the white chocolate sauce.  I might get it again, but likely would try another drizzle ... perhaps the mango coulis? Or peanut butter?

The kiwi and mango were again fabulous, on both top and bottom, so fresh, so ripe, so very good.  They were the exact right match for the tart style yogurt.

The macadamias were a major improvement over the candied nuts.  I was impressed by how many nuts they gave, both on the bottom and then perched all around the outside.  Macadamias are premium nuts, and they certainly did not skimp.  And of course, I could add more if I ran out.   They provided more than just a slight crunch, since whole nuts, and were a great flavor combo with both the mango and kiwi.  I'd definitely keep these again.

And finally, the pecan crunch on top and the hazelnut crunch on bottom.  I wasn't really sure what these were, they looked a bit like cereal, but crushed, so I didn't even pay attention to them on my first visit, but this time I asked, and was told they were the nut crunches.  But it clearly wasn't just crushed nuts.  I'm still confused as to what exactly these were, and I didn't taste them much given everything else in here.  Probably not worth getting, although  maybe they provided a bit of texture?

Refill! Fresh Strawberry & Kiwi.

This time, I went back for a refill.  Of fruit only.  

The kiwi was so fabulous that I got more, and I decided to try the strawberries too.  Both were ripe, fruity, fabulous.  Seriously such good fruit.

At this point my creation was fairly melty, and the fresh fruit, crunchy macadamias, thick chocolate Snicker's sauce, and melty froyo was fairly glorious.  I couldn't stop eating it.

Yeah, Oops?

Clearly.

I did actually go with a different plan.  I brought a travel freezer mug.  My plan was to get a froyo, eat one batch of toppings and froyo, get refills, eat just a little more, get refills, and *save the rest for later*.  But ... I couldn't stop!  I was actually really, really full, but I loved it so much.

So, next time.  What would I do differently?

I might consider not getting fruit in the bottom to start.  If I can keep adding it on top as long as I want, not really worth using up the space in the cup early on?  Then I can get more yogurt?  Maybe?  But if I did get fruit in the bottom, I'd get a sauce down there too I think.  Or maybe add sauce with refills?  The sauce and fruit are just so good together.

But I'd certainly get kiwi, mango, and strawberry.  No hesitation.  Same with the macadamias.  No question.  I'd get sauces, again trying two more, probably chocolate based this time?  Maybe some crushed non-candied nuts?  Maybe the sour cherries, as everyone else ordering froyo around me was getting them (including the lady before me, who got only the cherries, nothing else!).  Maybe some chips for crunch? 

Or maybe ... gelato?  I must just keep returning ...